You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

Cigar Geeks News
10th Annual Cigar for the Troops DriveBy: SenorPablo
The 10th Annual “Cigars for Troops” drive is underway. This is a great opportunity to give back to those who protect our freedoms and earn the coveted "Troop Supporter" badge at the same time. You can find information here: A special thanks goes out to Nathan (nwb) for running the drive again.
Toys for Tots Drive 2018By: SenorPablo
If you have not seen it, the 2018 Marine Toys for Tots drive is in full swing. This is an excellent opportunity for the brotherhood to contribute to a great organization that provides gifts for those less fortunate children in time for Christmas. A special thanks goes out to Emerson (McBryde) for stepping up to run the drive this year. Also, we are introducing a new Toys for Tots badge this year for being a contributor. If you gave a kit for auction, win an auction, or donate at least $25 you will earn the new badge
April Points Contest is Under Way!By: SenorPablo
The points contest is under way for the month of April. The 26 members with the most points for the month have a chance to win a $25 gift certificate to Famous Smoke Shop. You can read the details HERE. To view the previous month's contest results see here.

Recent Forum Posts   [All Forums]   [New Posts Since Last Visit]
Bstessl hit me within days!Last: Adwinistrator (13 replies)
4/25/2019 10:59 PM
Today’s Smoke April 2019Last: Koop (248 replies)
4/25/2019 10:30 PM
One Year AfterLast: bstessl (6 replies)
4/25/2019 10:00 PM
What's in the mail Part VIIILast: gitfiddl (108 replies)
4/25/2019 6:14 PM
NHL PlayoffsLast: Silverstix (5 replies)
4/25/2019 1:04 PM
Tatuaje 15th Anniversary Claro?Last: nickthafish (2 replies)
4/25/2019 10:38 AM
What Did I Miss?Last: Kid Montana (3 replies)
4/25/2019 9:09 AM
Rocky Mountain Cigar Festival (2019)...Last: arrow34 (4 replies)
4/25/2019 9:09 AM
Very Belated March Points ContestLast: shakinghorizons (5 replies)
4/25/2019 8:29 AM
The Get To Know Ya PassLast: Adwinistrator (44 replies)
4/24/2019 7:08 PM
May Member Sponsored Geek CritiqueLast: 05Venturer (43 replies)
4/24/2019 4:59 PM
Fox Cigar La Gloria Cubana Esteli 5 pack for 14.99Last: tuck0411 (3 replies)
4/24/2019 3:56 PM
MusicCity Dropping Bombs!Last: ntanner (12 replies)
4/24/2019 2:14 PM
It has been a long time, for me and my cigarsLast: junglepete (21 replies)
4/24/2019 9:18 AM
Where to start with Padron?Last: tuck0411 (13 replies)
4/23/2019 3:24 PM

Cigar Geeks Critiques - Vendor Sponsored [All Geek Critiques]
Camacho Liberty 2005 ThrowbackAugust, 201893
CG Rating
Written by Cigar Geeks Member: Jason (jharrisx5)
I'll preface my conclusion with an admission... I'm a big fan of the Camacho Liberty line of cigars.... Read More
Camacho Liberty 2005 ThrowbackAugust, 201890
CG Rating
Written by Cigar Geeks Member: Chuck (Cfickter)
I have not smokes the original 2005 so I have no true comparison, but I have smoked every one since ... Read More
Camacho Liberty 2005 ThrowbackAugust, 201891
CG Rating
Written by Cigar Geeks Member: Don Miller (DonM)
I really enjoyed this Liberty as I do every year.  The cigar smoked very well with nice fl... Read More
Camacho Liberty 2005 ThrowbackAugust, 201872
CG Rating
Written by Cigar Geeks Member: Jeff (Cap10_Morgan)
Don't let the low score fool you.  If your only concern is construction, then this might n... Read More
Camacho Liberty 2005 ThrowbackAugust, 201884
CG Rating
Written by Cigar Geeks Member: Gustoff
I did not have the privilege to experience one of the actual 2005 Liberties that are so highly rated... Read More

Cigar Geeks Critiques - Member Sponsored [All Geek Critiques]
Casa Turrent 1880 SupremoApril, 201990
CG Rating
Written by Cigar Geeks Member: Byron (Beegerply)
Overall this is a very good cigar and would most defiantly smoke again. Although it was not overly c... Read More
Casa Turrent 1880 SupremoApril, 201987
CG Rating
Written by Cigar Geeks Member: Barry (benchjockey)
For me this was a good cigar—just not a GOOD one. With the Mexican San Andres wrapper I expected, an... Read More
Casa Turrent 1880 SupremoApril, 201981
CG Rating
Written by Cigar Geeks Member: Koop
I didn't know what to expect from a Mexican cigar - I haven't knowingly smoked one before. Maybe the... Read More
Casa Turrent 1880 SupremoApril, 201945
CG Rating
Written by Cigar Geeks Member: McBryde
Starting this cigar, the smell of a nice sweet rolled tobacco cigar I was looking forward to it imme... Read More
Casa Turrent 1880 SupremoApril, 201989
CG Rating
Written by Cigar Geeks Member: Brian (ninfiction)
Thank you to Brian for including me in the critique. Definitely close to full, medium + at the least... Read More

Recent Cigar Reviews [All Cigar Reviews] [Cigar Database]
Cigar Rating Reviewer Date
Sancho Panza (Cuban) Belicosos3.5 Star RatingSilverstix4/24/2019 7:36 AM
Bought as a single, so I do not know the box code. Rested for 2 months in my humidor.

I must say that construction was impeccable on this cigar. Draw was perfect, not a wind tunnel and not plugged up, just right in the sweet spot. The burn line was razor sharp too, no touch up required and no babysitting. One of the best constructed Cuban cigars that I've smoked.

Flavor profile was just ok - nothing offensive but nothing that WOWed me either. Very mild toasted tobacco to start, developed into a nice tasting salty/nutty type of profile and didn't really change much. No harshness or bitterness.
Starts mild-medium body and reaches medium body by the end.

Paired with Diplomatico rum which was actually a great pairing.

Total: 84
Cuban Rounds (by Ventura Cigar) Torpedo1 Star Ratingdruid4/22/2019 8:14 PM
I can see why there were no rating for this cigar.  Some soft spots, a medium brown wrapper, a couple small veins, & decent oils make for a nice looking stick.  PLA manure & yeast; PLT yeasty bread; PLD mod.  Normal light, mod easy draw, even burn, & leather smoke.  The flavor profile does not live up to the PL enticements.  Leather & earth are muddled by an almost compost-y overtone that pretty much ruins this stick.  The finish is too long for these terrible flavors.  The body runs a high medium.  I can find nothing to redeem this short-filler (yes, I autopsied) cigar.
Punch Rare Corojo Magnum4 Star Ratingtuck04114/21/2019 6:47 PM
Humidor time 169 days
Another stick I've had sitting around for awhile taking up humi space and I wanted something more flavorful after the two milder sticks I smoked earlier, so this one was next up.  Good looking box-pressed stick with a dark, very smooth, nearly vein-free, oily wrapper...

Punched it and PLD was nice and open.  Got an easy draw, good smoke volume, and even burn to start.

Flavor is not quite as full-bodied as I was hoping for, but adequate for the task at hand.  Got hints of leather and wood and just a bit of spice on retro.  A slight hint of bitter dark chocolate appeared in the 2nd half.

The grey ash was very fine and got knocked off at about 2" leaving a nice cone.  From there things were very uneventful down to the nub.

Pretty nice smoke, this one, with near-perfect construction.  The flavors were not quite in my wheelhouse, but the other three in my humi will make nice commute smokes if they perform as well as this one did.
Burn time: 1:16
Rating: 3.8/5
Oliva/ Studio Tabac 2nds Liga W Robusto3.5 Star Ratingtuck04114/21/2019 4:37 PM
Humidor time: 106 days
Have now smoked three of these and have had mixed results, as follows:

First - This one had a tight draw and meager smoke output all the way through but burned very evenly down to the nub.  Wrapper had some discoloration, so easy enough to see why it got culled to 2nd status.

Second - Started out with an easy draw and good smoke output and the first inch or so was a good smoke with an even burn, but it went south from there.  Following the first ash knock-off, the burn got lopsided in conjunction with the draw worsening and smoke output decreasing.  I think it had a large stem in the middle portion of the stick as there was a hard finger of ash sticking up at one point. Things improved in the last third with the burn evening out following a touch-up and the draw and smoke output improving.  Exterior of this one was a bit rough looking with a patchy looking wrapper and a wrinkled cap.  Again, an obvious 2nd.

Third - Similar performance as the first one - tight draw and thin smoke most of the way through, but it gradually improved and reached nearly optimal in the last third.  Very even burn down to the nub with tight ash and nice cones left after the two de-ashings.  Best looking stick of the three with only one large vein running most of its length.  

Just prior to smoking the third one this afternoon, I smoked a Gilberto Oliva Reserva Blanc Robusto hoping to confirm this was the 2nd of that stick.  They both appear, from the available information, to have the same blend and wrapper.  Wrapper shade is close, although it doesn't appear identical, at least to my eyes.  The pic below shows two "W" 2nds, a Reserva Blanc, and a Connecticut Reserve, although I'm convinced this 2nd is not the CR due to the difference in flavor profile.  (The CR's 2nd is the "Liga F", IMO.)  At any rate, I can't conclude that the "W" is the 2nd of the Reserva Blanc as the flavor profile also does not seem to match.  Both are pleasant tasting smokes on the mild end, but the RB leans more towards Medium with more flavor than I was getting out of the "W".  I'd be interested to get someone else's take on this, hopefully someone with more experience and a more developed palate...

Additionally, as I've found with other Oliva 2nds I've tried to match to their production sticks, the vitolas do not exactly match, to wit:  Liga W 2nd - Churchill (7x50), Corona Extra (6.5x44), Gordo (6x60), Robusto (5x50), Toro 6x50), Toro Extra (6.5x62), and Reserva Blanc - Churchill (7x50), Corona (5.75x43), Robusto (5x50), Toro (6x50, Torpedo (6x52).

Conclusion - I'm thinking this is probably the 2nd of some other Oliva-made stick, possibly one under another brand name.  I'm not seeing any other Connecticut-wrappered sticks in the DB under the Oliva brand that might be a match.  
Burn time:  1:03 for the first, 1:15 for the third (I didn't time the second one).  For the record, the burn time for the RB I smoked today was 1:03.
Pinar del Rio Habano Sun Grown Torpedo (original blend)3.5 Star Ratingtuck04114/20/2019 10:31 PM
Humidor time: 156 days
Decided to dig another PDR out of the humi and see if it might do any better than the Oscuro I had earlier.  This one, like the first one, had a number of bumps and veins adorning the wrapper.  It also felt somewhat soft to the touch...

Punched it and PLD was good. Got an easy draw, good smoke volume, and an even burn to start.  

Flavors were medium-bodied with notes of earth, wood, and grass.  Not my usual preferred profile, but it was quite pleasant enough for puffing...

The burn was very even both before and after I knocked the first ash off at 1 1/2".  However, after the second de-ashing, things got uneven with the burn and a touch-up was needed.  And then another before reaching the nub.

This was a loosely packed stick that burnt quickly for its size.  Even so, I was hoping to be able to give it at least a 4.0 based on the performance of the first half and the pleasant taste, but the touch-ups required in the 2nd half knock the score down somewhat.  I have a few more of these which will get smoked on future commutes and will update this review should they perform any differently than this one did.
Burn time:  1:06
Rating: 3.7/5
5 Vegas Series A Apotheosis3.5 Star Ratingtuck04114/20/2019 6:32 PM
Humidor time: 180 days
I think this is only my second 5V stick, the first being the Gold, so I was overdue to try another one.  This was a good-looking box-pressed stick and had a very smooth, almost vein-free, dark, oily wrapper.

Punched it and PLD was good.  Got an easy draw, good smoke volume, and an even burn to start things off.

Flavor is full-bodied with notes of leather and cocoa.  Very nice.

The burn got wavy 1/2" in, then self-corrected over the course of the next inch or so. Knocked the fine ash off at 1 1/2" leaving a small cone.  The burn again got wavy after the ash left, then proceeded to lopsided at which point I gave it a touch-up. It got lopsided again and then tried to go out on me with about 2" left, so got a second touch-up before reaching the nub.

A pretty good, tasty smoke, this one, but the construction issues affecting the burn knock it down a few points.  I have four more of these and will update this review if those behave any better.
Burn time: 1:41
Rating: 3.7/5

Update: Smoked another one of these on the way home today and it didn't have the burn issues the first one had.  The draw and smoke volume weren't quite optimal, but this one had a very even, self-correcting burn line all the way through and never tried to go out on me.  Leaving the rating where it is for now and will update further if warranted.
Pinar del Rio Oscuro (original blend) Toro3 Star Ratingtuck04114/20/2019 3:09 PM
Humidor time: Between mine and someone else's... somewhere around 3000 days...
I think this is my first PDR stick, outside of a few 2nds and "short run" sticks that I got in a Thompson sampler last year.  It was a bit veiny and bumpy in appearance and had a very dark, oily wrapper...

Punched it and PLD was good.  Got an easy draw, good smoke volume, and a wavy burn to start.

Flavor profile is full-bodied with a strong note of leather and a bit of spice on retro.  Pretty nice and about what I was expecting based on the dark wrapper.

The burn got lopsided in the first inch so gave it a touch-up.  Knocked the first of the crumbly, grey ash off at 1 1/2" followed by further lopsidedness in the burn line, which got it a 2nd touch-up.  And that's pretty much the story of this one with further unevenness in the burn and several more touch-ups down to the nub.

Pretty nice flavor and it only scores as high as it does for that reason alone as the construction was pretty lacking.  I hope the rest of my various PDR sticks perform better than this one...
Burn time: 1:34
Rating: 3.1/5
La Palina Red Label Petit Lancero3.5 Star Ratingtuck04114/19/2019 10:01 PM
Humidor time: 97 days
Was gifted this stick by Ozz awhile back and figured I'd finally check it out and see if I wanted to bite on the 15 stick LP sampler deal Cigar Page currently has going.  It's kind of a rustic looking stick with a number of bumps and veins.  Seems firmly packed, too...

Gave it a punch and PLD was moderately open.  The light produced a slightly tight draw, less than optimal smoke volume, and an even burn to start things off.

Flavors are in the medium-bodied range with notes of grass and wood and a bit of spice on retro.  Not my favorite sort of profile but pleasant enough for puffing while, you guessed it, watching Netflix (Punisher Season 2 for those taking notes...)

The burn got wavy a half inch in and this proceeded to lopsided.  Knocked the ash off at about 1" on one side of the stick and 1 1/2" on the other.  It didn't show signs of self-correcting after this, so gave it a touch-up, and then a second touch-up was needed before reaching the nub. On the bright side, the draw and smoke volume both improved quite a bit in the first third and the stick became quite smokeable in spite of its lack of quality construction.

Not the most impressive of sticks, so I think I'll pass on the Cigar Page sampler, at least for now.  I have two other varieties of LP that I haven't tried yet, so we'll see how those treat me.
Burn time: 1:08
Rating: 3.4/5
Warped La Relatos4 Star RatingSilverstix4/19/2019 12:26 PM
Rested 3 months @ 65%.  This was my first smoke out of the box.

Appearance: 10/10 - I have become a big fan of the long skinnies, and this one was a excellent example. The mottled Colorado colored wrapper was full of small spider veins, but there were a good amount of oils to the wrapper and the seams were damn near invisible. It feels perfect in the hand, packed and rolled very well. Also sports a triple cap. A musk, sweet/sour/spice smell coming from the pre-light. Not overpowering, but it's there.

Smoking Characteristics: 18/20 - Burn I'd give a 8 out of 10 overall.  I did have to re-light once, but the burn line itself was very very good, no babysitting this bad boy. The draw was right in the sweet spot and couldn't have been better.

Taste: 31/35 - It took until the end of the 1/3 for this cigar to really get going for me. It was a generic woodsy/spicey/cedar/oak deal early on, albeit a very smooth smoke and the retro provided just the right amount of tingle. As I got into the 2/3 this cigar started to shine with a vanilla sweetness coming through to compliment the now rich cedar and oak. These notes came on in spades during the 2/3 and into the 3/3. As I approached the band, the cigar went back to what I was getting early on with unimpressive flavors in a very smooth delivery.

Overall: 30/35 - A very well constructed cigar that is easy to smoke without having to worry about the burn or the draw. The flavor profile was good, I enjoyed it overall and I would recommend picking up a 5'er of these especially if you enjoy the long skinnies. The 2/3 was the best part of the cigar, if it started that way from the beginning this would be a near perfect experience.

TOTAL: 89 Points
La Palina Classic Connecticut Robusto3.5 Star Ratingtuck04114/16/2019 6:53 PM
Humidor time: 140 days
This one had a smooth, slightly oily wrapper with a couple of minor veins.  Gave it a punch and PLD was good.  Got an easy draw, good smoke volume, with the burn starting slightly wavy.

Flavor is mild and pleasant with a slight hint of cream. Typical profile for Conny-wrappered sticks in my experience.

The burn evened out in the first inch and remained that way through the course of the smoke.  The ash dropped at about 1 1/2" leaving a nice cone.  From there things were uneventful down to the nub apart from me pulling a stem out of the punch hole in the last third after feeling a slight protrusion against my lip.  

Pretty nice smoke thanks to the quality construction and pleasant, if one-dimensional, taste.  I'll look forward to smoking the other five I have on the commute...
Burn time: 1:29
Rating: 3.7/5

The CG iPhone and Android apps are both here now!

Get your Geek Wear

Open Cigar Passes
[All Cigar Passes]
The Get To Know Ya Pass
(In Progess)

Recent Articles [All Articles]
  Pay it Forward (PIF)
  Seasoning a Humidor, by Hebron
  The Habana Barcode Story
  Is it Mold or Plume?
  Bulk Photo File Processing
  Dominican Republic Travel Guide by Analyze
  Drying out Over Humidified Beads
  HOW TO: Build a Coolidor
  Freezing Cigars by Jackal
  Inserting photos into posts, by Hot Stuff x

Recent Photos

(Delete all cookies set by this site)

Connect with us:   

Home  |  Contact Us  |  Advertise  |  Cigar Passes  |  Cigar Database  |  Virtual Humidor  |  Forums 

Copyright © 2007-2019 Cigar Geeks, Inc. All rights reserved.    Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service