Sticky PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read
junglepete
Posted 6/5/2014 7:15 AM (#472117)
Subject: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Extreme Guru

Joined: 3/16/2008

Posts: 8504
500020001000500

Points: 51924
50005000500050005000500050005000500050001000500100100100100
Feedback Rating: 97


Badges:
Dear Members,

As our site continues to grow, the interest for Geek Critques increase. We are currently reviewing four cigars per month, two via retail sponsorship and two via member sponsorship. In order to continue our progress with this venture it is imperative to not only keep ahead of the demand in an organized fashion, but most importantly to honor our sponsors by providing reviewers who can adhere to our posted deadlines.

Beginning today, a reviewer who posts their review late will receive neutral feedback. A reviewer who does not post at all will receive negative feedback. There are always exceptions to the rule, and a reasonable excuse for tardiness or a no show will be respected and thus not counted against the reviewer. Our sponsoring members and our administrators make the choice of who is to participate in any particular Geek Critique and can be better informed of their choices with this new initiative in place.

Our retail sponsors trust our site and our members in order to have their cigar exceptionally reviewed. In exchange, we promise those reviews to be posted for two weeks on our home page. It is in our best interest to adhere to our part of the bargain and get those five reviews posted accordingly. Our member sponsors are extremely generous. They not only provide a cigar for a reviewer to review, but they quite often send something extra along as well. On top of this, they ship it to your door for free. And on top of everything else, they do it five times over. The very least a reviewer can do is to get the review in on time and communicate when they cannot.

You may have noticed that due dates are usually scheduled for one week before the actual posting day. This is because the reviews need to first be edited by our admins and then passed on to Paul to organize them with pics, headers and footers. Please allow us the time to do this work by submitting your reviews on time. In most cases we are well organized and make great efforts to ensure the cigar arrives at your door well in advance of the due date. We will continue our efforts to give the reviewer access to the review template as soon as possible.

The best way to avoid any neutral or negative feedback would be to communicate with either the sponsor or the coordinating admin before the deadline. It is not only imperative to the scheduled process, but mostly it is being respectful to the sponsors and those behind the scene working to get the reviews posted according to our commitments.

A special thanks goes out to all of our sponsors and reviewers. Your Geek Critique sponsorship and participation is greatly valued, assuredly appreciated, and an integral part of our successful community.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
nwb
Posted 6/5/2014 7:50 AM (#472133 - in reply to #472117)
Subject: RE: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Elite Guru

Joined: 7/13/2009

Posts: 30005
500050005000500050005000

Points: 38225
50005000500050005000500050002000100010010025
Feedback Rating: 282
Location: Atlanta, GA

Badges:
Top of the page Bottom of the page
The Burn Ward
Posted 6/5/2014 8:02 AM (#472135 - in reply to #472117)
Subject: RE: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Extreme Expert

Joined: 8/23/2013

Posts: 3755
200010005001001002525

Points: 6810
50001000500100100100
Feedback Rating: 95


Badges:
Thanks for all the effort that goes into the GC's.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
StogieDad
Posted 6/5/2014 8:07 AM (#472136 - in reply to #472117)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Extreme Guru

Joined: 5/23/2013

Posts: 9008
500020002000

Points: 21233
5000500050005000100010010025
Feedback Rating: 352
Location: North Atlanta Burbs

Badges:
Very valid points. A lot more than we probably realize goes into these, kudos to the admins for handling those.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
DonM
Posted 6/5/2014 8:42 AM (#472141 - in reply to #472117)
Subject: RE: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Elite Guru

Joined: 1/11/2009

Posts: 12657
5000500020005001002525

Points: 17532
500050005000200050025
Feedback Rating: 79
Location: The Nature Coast

Badges:
There are not too many excuses that I would call good ones for missing the deadline. You get free cigars and in plenty of time for a review. I slipped ONCE and still got it in by the due date. The sponsors, admins and Paul put their efforts in to make these happen, as a reviewer you should too.

Now that I added my $.02 I am off to smoke a cigar
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Ken Kelley
Posted 6/5/2014 9:03 AM (#472142 - in reply to #472117)
Subject: RE: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Elite Guru

Joined: 12/2/2008

Posts: 14520
5000500020002000500

Points: 17120
5000500050002000100
Feedback Rating: 54
Location: A ways up Indian Creek, Kentucky

Badges:
Hear, hear! I'm still waiting to hear from a certain AWOL participant in my Illusione mj12 episode!
Top of the page Bottom of the page
toby2
Posted 6/5/2014 9:09 AM (#472143 - in reply to #472117)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Extreme Guru

Joined: 4/14/2012

Posts: 9477
500020002000100100100100252525

Points: 11062
5000500010002525
Feedback Rating: 91
Location: Fortson GA

Badges:
sorry about a day late on my last one. I had been pretty darn sick and still was when I smoked it. thx again.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
BewareDaPenguin
Posted 6/5/2014 9:16 AM (#472147 - in reply to #472117)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Extreme Expert

Joined: 1/3/2014

Posts: 3435
2000100010010010010025

Points: 5400
5000100100100100
Feedback Rating: 120


Badges:
Thanks again for all the behind the scenes work you guys do.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
ntanner
Posted 6/5/2014 9:18 AM (#472148 - in reply to #472117)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Guru

Joined: 4/19/2011

Posts: 7483
50002000100100100100252525

Points: 11968
5000500010005001001001001002525
Feedback Rating: 43
Location: Sasquatch territory

Badges:
Thanx for the reminder of the fact that it is a privilege to be picked to do a critique so if you want to keep the privilege do the work. Besides, how hard is it to look a cigar over and smoke it. I find it enjoyable, thus the reason I am here, and it is an honor to be picked, it shows some one values you're opinion enough to post it on the site for 2 week's. Or in my case that a volunteered enough they gave in to shut me up. Either way, thanx for the ones you have let me review and thanx to all the staff that keep's this place running.

Edited by ntanner 6/5/2014 9:20 AM
Top of the page Bottom of the page
nirab
Posted 6/5/2014 9:20 AM (#472150 - in reply to #472136)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Elite Guru

Joined: 5/6/2012

Posts: 12209
500050002000100100

Points: 18949
5000500050002000100050010010010010025
Feedback Rating: 338
Location: Beeuudaful Buda, Texas! HOOK EM! \m/

Badges:
Also, it is just the right thing to do. Thanks for posting this.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
nwb
Posted 6/5/2014 9:37 AM (#472160 - in reply to #472143)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Elite Guru

Joined: 7/13/2009

Posts: 30005
500050005000500050005000

Points: 38225
50005000500050005000500050002000100010010025
Feedback Rating: 282
Location: Atlanta, GA

Badges:
toby2 - 6/5/2014 12:09 PM

sorry about a day late on my last one. I had been pretty darn sick and still was when I smoked it. thx again.


Correct me if I'm wrong, Pete, but being sick would qualify for a delay. It happens.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
ROTHNH
Posted 6/5/2014 10:00 AM (#472173 - in reply to #472160)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read


Elite Expert

Joined: 8/26/2008

Posts: 5175
5000100252525

Points: 10775
50005000500100100252525
Feedback Rating: 1
Location: Midcoast Maine

Badges:
nwb - 6/5/2014 12:37 PM

toby2 - 6/5/2014 12:09 PM

sorry about a day late on my last one. I had been pretty darn sick and still was when I smoked it. thx again.


Correct me if I'm wrong, Pete, but being sick would qualify for a delay. It happens.


I would certainly think so!

But the reality of life is that 99% of the time, if you make a commitment, you follow through with it... I've been a Geek for some years now and I've seen very few problems.

I'm very much in support of using negative feedback so we know where the problems are.


Edited by ROTHNH 6/5/2014 10:01 AM
Top of the page Bottom of the page
tvolball
Posted 6/5/2014 10:03 AM (#472174 - in reply to #472141)
Subject: RE: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Elite Expert

Joined: 11/14/2012

Posts: 4912
20002000500100100100100

Points: 7122
50002000100
Feedback Rating: 83


Badges:
Well stated. If you sign up for a review, you need to plan it into your schedule.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
junglepete
Posted 6/5/2014 11:04 AM (#472193 - in reply to #472160)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Extreme Guru

Joined: 3/16/2008

Posts: 8504
500020001000500

Points: 51924
50005000500050005000500050005000500050001000500100100100100
Feedback Rating: 97


Badges:
nwb - 6/5/2014 12:37 PM

Correct me if I'm wrong, Pete, but being sick would qualify for a delay. It happens.




For sure being sick would qualify as a valid reason for missing a deadline...as long as it is communicated before hand. However, if one leaves the review to the very last day when they had weeks to smoke it, it seems that a little more effort could be made with personal scheduling so as not to be in a last day crunch.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
c.petree.1
Posted 6/5/2014 11:07 AM (#472195 - in reply to #472117)
Subject: RE: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Expert

Joined: 4/25/2013

Posts: 1271
10001001002525

Points: 2431
200010010010010025
Feedback Rating: 50
Location: Atlanta, GA.

Badges:
Top of the page Bottom of the page
nwb
Posted 6/5/2014 12:00 PM (#472208 - in reply to #472193)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Elite Guru

Joined: 7/13/2009

Posts: 30005
500050005000500050005000

Points: 38225
50005000500050005000500050002000100010010025
Feedback Rating: 282
Location: Atlanta, GA

Badges:
junglepete - 6/5/2014 2:04 PM
...if one leaves the review to the very last day when they had weeks to smoke it, it seems that a little more effort could be made with personal scheduling so as not to be in a last day crunch.


That is a very good point.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Vroomp
Posted 6/5/2014 12:10 PM (#472214 - in reply to #472208)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Extreme Guru

Joined: 7/29/2012

Posts: 8979
500020001000500100100100100252525

Points: 16169
50005000500010001002525
Feedback Rating: 314
Location: 'Hotlanta' Near the big chicken!

Badges:

I hear that!

 

 Really bugged me to see one of the last reviewers ignore several PMs, then sign onto the site the day before posting date and still offer no excuse....

I really wanted to give poor feedback but, this rule was not in place at that time!

Can we make this retroactive?  

Top of the page Bottom of the page
nwb
Posted 6/5/2014 1:11 PM (#472239 - in reply to #472214)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Elite Guru

Joined: 7/13/2009

Posts: 30005
500050005000500050005000

Points: 38225
50005000500050005000500050002000100010010025
Feedback Rating: 282
Location: Atlanta, GA

Badges:
Vroomp - 6/5/2014 3:10 PM
Can we make this retroactive?  


We don't want to open that bag of worms....
Top of the page Bottom of the page
junglepete
Posted 6/5/2014 3:56 PM (#472288 - in reply to #472239)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Extreme Guru

Joined: 3/16/2008

Posts: 8504
500020001000500

Points: 51924
50005000500050005000500050005000500050001000500100100100100
Feedback Rating: 97


Badges:
Bump
Top of the page Bottom of the page
sjn1117
Posted 6/5/2014 4:23 PM (#472298 - in reply to #472117)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Guru

Joined: 5/23/2012

Posts: 6546
5000100050025

Points: 7856
500020005001001001002525
Feedback Rating: 65
Location: texas boondocks

Badges:
I am guilty admittedly on the last one I did and the point is definitely taken and understood by all means. I did have some out of my control crap come up but I agree totally that these are a privilege and not a gift. I appreciate all that you admins do to keep this place rolling smoothly.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
bmac7754
Posted 6/5/2014 6:27 PM (#472313 - in reply to #472117)
Subject: RE: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Guru

Joined: 12/31/2011

Posts: 6755
500010005001001002525

Points: 17345
500050005000200010010010025
Feedback Rating: 201
Location: Massachusetts

Badges:
, and a positive should be left too for those who get them done.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
sauraspop
Posted 6/5/2014 7:25 PM (#472328 - in reply to #472117)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Expert

Joined: 1/8/2014

Posts: 1320
1000100100100

Points: 2750
20005001001002525
Feedback Rating: 40
Location: Sweet Home Alabama

Badges:
I think being selected to do a Greek Critique is an honor, and if accepted, an obligation. It's a shame to have to make more rules but necessary I guess. S..t happens but still an obligation to be performed. My 2 cents and thanks for all the work you Geeks do behind the scenes to make these Critiques available and enjoyed.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
nwb
Posted 6/7/2014 10:35 AM (#472599 - in reply to #472298)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Elite Guru

Joined: 7/13/2009

Posts: 30005
500050005000500050005000

Points: 38225
50005000500050005000500050002000100010010025
Feedback Rating: 282
Location: Atlanta, GA

Badges:
sjn1117 - 6/5/2014 7:23 PM
I am guilty admittedly on the last one I did and the point is definitely taken and understood by all means. I did have some out of my control crap come up but I agree totally that these are a privilege and not a gift. I appreciate all that you admins do to keep this place rolling smoothly.


Here's the difference: you at least kept us in the loop on what was happening. If we have communication from the reviewer, it goes a long way in keeping these running smoothly.

That isn't to say a person who submits a late review will get a free pass, but that person will get far more leniency than no communication at all.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Joelala
Posted 6/7/2014 11:17 AM (#472610 - in reply to #472117)
Subject: Re: PSA - New Geek Critique Initiative - Please Read



Extreme Expert

Joined: 2/7/2013

Posts: 2745
200050010010025

Points: 4330
2000200010010010025
Feedback Rating: 111


Badges:
I complerely agree and support this. I have only done one critique and we had plenty of time to get it done.
Top of the page Bottom of the page