I finally got to check out this place. They must pay a lot for rent, which explains their prices. If you ask for a 10% discount, they'll probably give it to you, and that corrects for the overpricing. I use the price of a Red Dot Cohiba Churchill as my benchmark for testing prices. Under 15 is below average. 15-15.50 is average. Above that is no bargain. Here they were $16.95, but with a 10% discount, they are average.
I bought the following:
Padron 6000 Natural Torpedo, $7.60
Hoyo de Monterrey Hoyo de Tradicion Fat Box-Pressed Toro Natural (forgot price)
Private Stock No. 1, 7.75x48, $4.69
I've been doing a lot of shopping at Serious
Cigars.com because they sell a ton of singles and at good prices.