As everyone knows by now, the Republican-held PA State Senate passed the budget and Rendell's 30% Tobacco tax was quashed. But there are comments, of course, from both sides.
First the sore losers (the SORRY ABOUT YOUR LUCK bunch!) From the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review: "Pennsylvania remains the only state in the nation without a tax on smokeless tobacco. It and Florida don't tax cigars. That makes public health a loser under the budget, said Melinda Little, a regional director for Washington D.C.-based Tobacco Free Kids. '"We know that higher taxes on these products prevent usage, especially with kids," Little said. The organization's figures show 12.9 percent of high school boys in Pennsylvania use snuff, 17.7 percent smoke cigars and 18 percent smoke cigarettes.' " (And just forget the fact that you'd be putting how many business out and jobs erased. Typical liberalspeak)
and from
pennlive.com: "Deborah Brown, acting CEO of the American Lung Association of the Mid-Atlantic, was astounded that Pennsylvania would remain the only state in the nation that doesn't tax smokeless tobacco and one of only two that don't tax cigars. She said if those products were taxed at the same rate as cigarettes, it could have produced $90 million to $100 million.
"I can't believe they left this money on the table and they'd rather see people laid off from their jobs than to tax these products," Brown said." (read my say above)
The winners (republicans)Tribune-Review: "But Sen. Patrick Brown, R-Allentown, who represents two cigar retailers in the Lehigh Valley, said taxing the companies could force them to relocate and cost the region and state more than 1,500 jobs." (I read from
stogieguys.com that if this passed, Cigars International would have joined Kingston, NY's Uptown Cigars by also moving to Florida!)
"I'm not willing to play a game of chicken with hundreds of jobs," said Senate Appropriations Chairman Jake Corman, R-Centre County."
I contacted my state rep, Carl Metzgar (R 69th District of PA), and here's part of his letter:
"I can assure you that I am not in favor of further tobacco taxation in PA. Constituents of the Commonwealth are already over taxed and this attempt to impose additional taxes on tobacco products will only hurt our local businesses and their contractors, and is completely unnecessary. Fiscal commom sense is needed to balance our state's budget, not taxing tobacco."