Menu

Cigar Geeks Geek Critique

Isabela Miami Robusto
Written by Cigar Geeks Member: Hot Stuff x (Hot Stuff x)

89
Cigar Geeks Rating

Welcome to another Cigar Geeks Critique of a cigar provided to us by Isabela Cigar Company. They have generously provided a number of their various sizes for us to review.



Isabela Miami Robusto

Brand:
Isabela
Name:
Miami Robusto
Length:
5
Ring Gauge:
52
Country of Origin:
United States
Filler:
Honduras
Binder:
Nicaragua
Wrapper:
Ecuador
Color:
Colorado Maduro
Strength:
Mild-Medium
Shape:
Robusto
Average Member Rating:
3.32 star rating based on 11 Review(s) (11 Review(s))
This cigar was enjoyed with Water

Pre-Light: 17 Points of 10 Possible

This cigar is a mottled, medium-brown color.  It is an attractive cigar with a Cohiba-esque band.  The wrapper was mostly smooth but this example had one very prominent vein near the cap with detracted from the overall apperance.   The pre-light aroma was that of quality tobacco with just a bit of an alfalfa aroma as well.  The cigar was firmly packed with no soft spots, and had a good heft to it.

Lighting and Burn: 13 Points of 15 Possible

I used a guillotine cut and toasted the foot before lighting.  The cigar lit evenly, and the burn stayed pretty straight for the duration, with no touch-ups required.  I did, however, have to re-light the cigar during the last 1/3.  For the first two-thirds I could take several minutes between puffs, but as I got closer to the nub, the cigar required more attention to remain lit.  The ash was light gray and a bit flaky, with tiny bits of ash flying off with each puff.  I let the ash hold for about the first 1/2 inch, but it was starting to develop some San Andreas style faults, so I set it over the ashtray and gently tapped to see if the ash would hold--and it promptly dropped into the tray.  After that I kept the ash short to avoid dropping any on me.  

The cigar produced great plumes of smoke with each puff, and burned very slowly.  I unfortunately forgot to write down the start time so I could get an overall total burn time for this stick, but I know it was well over an hour.

Construction: 27 Points of 30 Possible

The cigar appears to be skillfully wrapped, with no apparent flaws in any of the seams, and it had a nicely done triple cap.  The pre-light draw was very good, and the draw remained very good for the duration of the cigar.  A look at the foot of the cigar revealed a center of dark leaves surrounded by leaves of a lighter shade. Overall I thought this was a beauty of a cigar and has a very high-end, premium look about it.

Flavor and Aroma: 32 Points of 45 Possible

During the pre-light draw I tasted quite a bit of spicyness.  After lighting it up, the flavor was very bold but smooth.  This is a very full bodied cigar, an dit really coats the palate with flavor.  I was already light-headed just 2" into the smoke, despite taking time between puffs.  The room note was very strong, but was the pleasant aroma of a quality cigar.  Although the smoke was smooth, I couldn't help noticing a mild stinging/harshness at the top of my throat.  The flavors I noted were oak, tobacco, cut hay, and even a slight floral note.  Not a strong floral like honeysuckle or rose, just a gentle "clean" floral like maybe carnation.  At the 1/2 way point I got a couple puffs that were a little bitter, and I was thinking it was from tar buildup.  But then the flavor changed and the floral note became a bit more pronounced than before.  

In the final 1/3 the flavors changed again slightly, with the floral notes disappering and the predominant flavor being just good quality tobacco.



Summary

This is a very high quality, full-bodied cigar.  Although very good, I would love to have some of these to place in the humi and give them a year or two of rest. I am admittedly a bit of a lightweight, and I think I would enjoy these cigars a bit more if the strength was muted just a bit.  As it is, I was surprised at how smooth the cigar was.  Even so, I imagine that these would age exceptionally well.  


   
Privacy Policy     Terms of Service
Copyright © 2007-2024 Cigar Geeks, Inc. All rights reserved.