Print Page - March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)

Title: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: junglepete on 01/24/2015 05:58 PM

This Geek Critique has been generously sponsored by Ted (Ted).

The Cigar: Ashton Symmetry Belicoso (5.25 x 52)

The Hype: Ashton Symmetry cigars reveal a perfectly-proportioned and aged Dominican-Nicaraguan tobacco blend flawlessly rolled in Ecuadorian Habano wrappers so silky, you could make them into ties. As the first Ashton cigar blend to introduce Nicaraguan tobacco, Symmetry opens with crisp spice and woody notes as succeeding flavor nuances enter for a perfectly-balanced smoke, and eventually lead to a long, rousing finish.

The Reviewers: First four to respond to this thread that has not done any critique this year or is not slated for one in Jan. or Feb.

1. sar127 (Rob)
2. BewareDaPenguin (Adam)
3. Caveman Steve (Steve)
4. timpellis (Tim)
5. Michaelbevans61 (Bryce)

Due Date: February 23, 2015

Note: A reviewer who posts their review late will receive neutral feedback. A reviewer who does not post at all will receive negative feedback. There are always exceptions to the rule and a reasonable excuse for tardiness or a no show will be respected and thus not counted against the reviewer. Our sponsoring members and our administrators make the choice of who is to participate in any particular Geek Critique and can be better informed of their choices with this new initiative in place.

Thanks again to Ted for taking this one on and providing the cigar. THANKS!! And happy smokin' :smoker:

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 4 Reviewers Needed
Post by: Rammstein142 on 01/24/2015 06:38 PM

If its allowable, I just finished the Feb first 2 weeks and have the Feb last 2 weeks left, but I would be up for doing another review. Really enjoy doing these critiques! If not then no worries!! :-)

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 4 Reviewers Needed
Post by: BewareDaPenguin on 01/24/2015 06:41 PM

I'll throw my name in the hat for this one, love Ashton"s and would enjoy doing the review if you will have me. Haven't been on and not much time to smoke but the weather should be turning in time for me to do this review. Appreciate the consideration

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 4 Reviewers Needed
Post by: bmac7754 on 01/24/2015 11:14 PM

Id be up to doing if you need a hand. I did do the first week of January, but have nothing upcoming.

If others jump up and havnt done one, I don't want to bump them of their right. Rules are rules.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 4 Reviewers Needed
Post by: johncw on 01/25/2015 05:44 AM

Thanks for sponsoring Ted... I'm still waiting until it gets a little warmer before I throw my hat in the ring.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 4 Reviewers Needed
Post by: Caveman Steve on 01/25/2015 06:28 AM

I haven't done one in a while. I'll throw my name in the mix.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 4 Reviewers Needed
Post by: timpellis on 01/25/2015 06:31 AM

I'm game if needed.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 4 Reviewers Needed
Post by: ntanner on 01/25/2015 08:45 AM

Already have a February one but I love me some Ashton's so I will raise my hand just in case you need someone else.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 4 Reviewers Needed
Post by: Ted on 01/25/2015 11:08 AM

It looks like we have three volunteers who haven't done one yet so far (BewareDaPenguin, Caveman Steve, and timpellis)? Wanna leave it open one more day for someone who hasn't done one yet, then let Pete pick from the regulars! :D

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 4 Reviewers Needed
Post by: sar127 on 01/25/2015 12:27 PM

Thanks for the offer Ted! I don't know if I'm discerning enough to do a Critique but I guess I can give it a shot.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 4 Reviewers Needed
Post by: Cfickter on 01/25/2015 12:54 PM

Will throw my name into the hat if u need anyone

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 4 Reviewers Needed
Post by: junglepete on 01/26/2015 09:15 AM

1 more reviewer need folks.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 1 More Reviewer Needed
Post by: Cfickter on 01/26/2015 02:07 PM

My earlier offer still stands, I will do this one if needed

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 1 More Reviewer Needed
Post by: junglepete on 01/26/2015 02:16 PM

QuoteCfickter - 1/26/2015 5:07 PM

My earlier offer still stands, I will do this one if needed

Thanks Chuck, we're going to hold out a bit for someone who has yet to do one this year.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 1 More Reviewer Needed
Post by: Cfickter on 01/26/2015 03:26 PM

Not a problem. I would defer to anyone who wants to do one. Come on Geeks!

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 1 More Reviewer Needed
Post by: BewareDaPenguin on 01/26/2015 05:55 PM

Thanks for having me, and thanks to Ted for sponsoring the critique looking forward to this one :smoker:

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 1 More Reviewer Needed
Post by: Michaelbevans61 on 01/26/2015 06:00 PM

I'll throw my name in the hat guy's, I've never done one for the geeks Official, and I would like to give it a shot.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 1 More Reviewer Needed
Post by: junglepete on 01/26/2015 06:34 PM

QuoteMichaelbevans61 - 1/26/2015 9:00 PM

I'll throw my name in the hat guy's, I've never done one for the geeks Official, and I would like to give it a shot.

Okay Bryce, you're in :-)

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks) 1 More Reviewer Needed
Post by: Caveman Steve on 01/26/2015 06:46 PM

Really looking forward to trying this cigar. Thanks for having me!

:biggrin:

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Michaelbevans61 on 01/26/2015 06:57 PM

Looking forward to it!!!! THANKS A BUNCH GUYS!!

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Michaelbevans61 on 01/26/2015 07:33 PM

O and P.S Thanks ted for sponsoring the cigars!! Really looking forward to trying this bad boy out, I've only had a few Ashton's in my day, so I'm excited for this one.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: BewareDaPenguin on 01/27/2015 04:33 AM

QuoteMichaelbevans61 - 1/26/2015 9:33 PM

O and P.S Thanks ted for sponsoring the cigars!! Really looking forward to trying this bad boy out, I've only had a few Ashton's in my day, so I'm excited for this one.

This should be a real treat for you then brother, I've never smoked an Ashton I haven't liked all excellant smokes. The VSG line is one of my top 5 cigars and when I saw this I was lucky to be online to jump in, appreciate the chance to review. :thumbsup:

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Michaelbevans61 on 01/28/2015 11:02 AM

QuoteBewareDaPenguin - 1/27/2015 5:33 AM
QuoteMichaelbevans61 - 1/26/2015 9:33 PM O and P.S Thanks ted for sponsoring the cigars!! Really looking forward to trying this bad boy out, I've only had a few Ashton's in my day, so I'm excited for this one.
This should be a real treat for you then brother, I've never smoked an Ashton I haven't liked all excellant smokes. The VSG line is one of my top 5 cigars and when I saw this I was lucky to be online to jump in, appreciate the chance to review. :thumbsup:

I'm humbled that I get to do a geek critique, let alone on such a awesome cigar!!!! Thanks a bunch man! I have had a VSG and from what I remember, it was fantastic :smoker:

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Cfickter on 01/28/2015 11:03 AM

Looking forward to see the ratings and reviews. I like this cigar

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Michaelbevans61 on 01/28/2015 11:04 AM

Do we have a idea of when they are going to be sent out??

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Ted on 01/30/2015 10:40 AM

Hey guys, sorry haven't been here in a couple days! Packaging up as we speak. Will b taking to the post office this afternoon. I'll update with tracking numbers later today. Thanks for volunteering, and thanks junglepete for running all of these!

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Michaelbevans61 on 01/30/2015 03:43 PM

Sweeeeet excited!

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Michaelbevans61 on 01/30/2015 03:43 PM

Sweeeeet excited!

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Ted on 01/30/2015 04:14 PM

---

Here are the tracking numbers for the critique! Hope everyone enjoys these!

Caveman Steve 9405 9036 9930 0350 1343 77 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134377)

BewareDaPenguin 9405 9036 9930 0350 1344 07 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134407)

timpellis 9405 9036 9930 0350 1344 83 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134483)

sar127 9405 9036 9930 0350 1345 13 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134513)

Michaelbevans61 9405 9036 9930 0350 1345 68 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134568)

---

Was rearranging stock trying to prepare for some incoming boxes next week. Running low on room in the coolers! :-0 Figured I knew some volunteers who wouldn't mind helping me create space?

Cfickter 9405 9036 9930 0350 1345 37 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134537)

Rammstein142 9405 9036 9930 0350 1343 60 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134360)

ntanner 9405 9036 9930 0350 1343 91 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134391)

bmac7754 9405 9036 9930 0350 1344 69 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134469)

johncw 9405 9036 9930 0350 1344 76 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134476)

---

Just wanted to say thank you for running these all the time. Really appreciate it. I read the reviews regularly for help in determining my own tastes and planning on what to try. One of my favorite things about this site.

junglepete 9405 9036 9930 0350 1345 82 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134582)

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Michaelbevans61 on 01/31/2015 10:40 AM

Ted i didn't know u live in co as well BOTL!

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: sar127 on 01/31/2015 12:10 PM

QuoteTed - 1/30/2015 6:14 PM
---
Here are the tracking numbers for the critique! Hope everyone enjoys these!
Caveman Steve 9405 9036 9930 0350 1343 77 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134377)
BewareDaPenguin 9405 9036 9930 0350 1344 07 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134407)
timpellis 9405 9036 9930 0350 1344 83 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134483)
sar127 9405 9036 9930 0350 1345 13 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134513)
Michaelbevans61 9405 9036 9930 0350 1345 68 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134568)
---
Was rearranging stock trying to prepare for some incoming boxes next week. Running low on room in the coolers! :-0 Figured I knew some volunteers who wouldn't mind helping me create space?
Cfickter 9405 9036 9930 0350 1345 37 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134537)
Rammstein142 9405 9036 9930 0350 1343 60 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134360)
ntanner 9405 9036 9930 0350 1343 91 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134391)
bmac7754 9405 9036 9930 0350 1344 69 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134469)
johncw 9405 9036 9930 0350 1344 76 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134476)
---
Just wanted to say thank you for running these all the time. Really appreciate it. I read the reviews regularly for help in determining my own tastes and planning on what to try. One of my favorite things about this site.
junglepete 9405 9036 9930 0350 1345 82 (https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction%21input.action?tLabels=9405903699300350134582)

Bombs away!!!! :uzi: :puncher: :shotgun:

Title: RE: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: junglepete on 01/31/2015 05:00 PM

Wow...mighty generous of you Ted. So not necessary but greatly appreciated! Thanks, I'll keep an eye out for it. :dancing:

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: BewareDaPenguin on 01/31/2015 05:06 PM

Dang Ted very cool, thanks again for letting me participate in the critique love Ashton's and looking forward to smoking this stick :smoker:

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: timpellis on 01/31/2015 05:09 PM

Thanks Ted, looking forward to this! Been dying to try this exact stick.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Michaelbevans61 on 01/31/2015 07:14 PM

Thanks ted! Got mine today! Very Very generous of you, I GOT BOMBED HARD!!!! thanks a lot ted, looking forward to smoking this stick, can't wait to try it out!

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Ted on 02/01/2015 12:52 PM

QuoteMichaelbevans61 - 1/31/2015 11:40 AM Ted i didn't know u live in co as well BOTL!

Just got back from Breck. Ice sculptures were pretty cool this year. No skiing for us, but the town was absolutely packed.

And absolutely ZERO places to smoke a cigar indoors. :(

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Michaelbevans61 on 02/01/2015 02:26 PM

Ya i'm not liking what the state is doing to smoking. Also why I'm moving to NC next month

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Michaelbevans61 on 02/01/2015 02:27 PM

Hey could one of you guy's point me in the direction of that cigar ruler that we need to use for the picture? I would greatly appreciate it.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Ted on 02/01/2015 03:25 PM

QuoteMichaelbevans61 - 2/1/2015 3:27 PM Hey could one of you guy's point me in the direction of that cigar ruler that we need to use for the picture? I would greatly appreciate it.

http://www.cigargeeks.com/cigardb/CGCigarPhotoTemplate.pdf

Title: RE: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: timpellis on 02/02/2015 03:39 PM

Got my package in today, above and beyond, Ted. Thanks, your generosity is greatly appreciated!

Title: RE: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Caveman Steve on 02/02/2015 04:18 PM

Got Mine today also. Way too generous! Thanks Ted!

(http://www.cigargeeks.com/index.php?action=dlattach;attach=32325;image)

That's funny, my carpet looks just like Tim's!, and so do my cigars.......(Yes Tim.....I Hijacked your pic, but I am sick and need to go to bed. Took the easy way out) Love the SLR's. All they need is a bit of age.

Thanks again Ted. You're an A+ Geek.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: timpellis on 02/02/2015 04:39 PM

Hmmm, your carpet seems to have less dog hair than mine.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: sar127 on 02/02/2015 07:07 PM

Just got the box and I also was hit hard!!! Thanks a lot for the hitchhikers! Much Appreciated

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Michaelbevans61 on 02/03/2015 06:19 PM

QuoteTed - 2/1/2015 4:25 PM
QuoteMichaelbevans61 - 2/1/2015 3:27 PM Hey could one of you guy's point me in the direction of that cigar ruler that we need to use for the picture? I would greatly appreciate it.
http://www.cigargeeks.com/cigardb/CGCigarPhotoTemplate.pdf

Thanks ted greatly appreciate it! THANKS AGAIN FOR THE HITCHHIKERS!

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: junglepete on 02/04/2015 02:23 PM

Wow Ted, that was some bomb that just exploded. Hugely generous brother. I'm speechless! Thank you very much! Some great specialty smokes here...4/5 that will be a new experience for me too. Awsome. :-0

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: bmac7754 on 02/04/2015 02:47 PM

Nice. I wasn't part of this review so didn't read the thread. I didn't even notice the forewarning of the bomb I got.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: BewareDaPenguin on 02/04/2015 04:20 PM

Ted got me good as well!! Got the Ashton along with some nice bodyguard bombs! Appreciate it Ted!! Can't wait to get into this Ashton looking forward to the review! Thanks again!

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: sar127 on 02/10/2015 07:29 PM

When is this due btw?

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Ted on 02/11/2015 05:00 AM

2/23 Rob!

:smoker:

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Ted on 02/19/2015 06:24 AM

Hey all, just a reminder. Reviews due by Monday!
:bigthumbs:

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: timpellis on 02/19/2015 07:15 PM

I believe mine is in, good thing too it will be -7 tomorrow morning.

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: BewareDaPenguin on 02/20/2015 05:29 AM

Geez I thought it would warm up here!!! Looks like I'll be braving the cold to smoke this, was really hoping the weather would play nice but running out of time, thanks for the reminder :thumbsup:

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Ted on 02/21/2015 12:56 AM

Yeah, cold here too!
:angry:

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: BewareDaPenguin on 02/22/2015 01:34 PM

Review submitted, feedback left, thanks again! I appreciate it :thumbsup:

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Michaelbevans61 on 02/22/2015 02:44 PM

SUBMITTED MINE THE OTHER DAY! Thanks alot ted! Feedback submitted!

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: sar127 on 02/22/2015 07:20 PM

^^X2. Thanks a bunch for the opportunity. Had a blast doing my first review!

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Ted on 02/23/2015 12:40 AM

Thanks guys! Looking forward to reading!

Title: Re: March Member Sponsored Geek Critique (First Two Weeks)
Post by: Ted on 03/02/2015 05:59 AM

Great reviews guys, thanks! Can't wait for a warm weekend to try one. Feedback left!

Cigar Geeks

Cigar Geeks Site => Geek Critiques => Topic started by: junglepete on 01/24/2015 05:58 PM