Cigar Geeks

Members Lounge => Contests / Giveaways => Topic started by: ninfiction on 03/01/2016 04:41 PM

Title: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: ninfiction on 03/01/2016 04:41 PM
Here's the deal, smoke a cigar that another Geek(member of this forum) has given you, complete a review for the cigar, post here with the cigar name and the Geek's name the gave it to you and you're entered. Easy right? Yep, that's it. Smoke, type, win cigars.
 
The nitty gritty:

1) This contest will run the entire month of March (Midnight Central time March 31st 2016)
2) You must be of veteran status by the end of the contest, I assume if you've been here long enough to have received cigars from another geek you'll have your 60 days in without issue by March 31st...and if you don't have 100 posts, get to it.
3) The Geek that provided the cigar must be a member of Cigar Geeks.
4) You must complete a review for said cigar in the database.
5) You must post in this thread by the deadline which cigar you reviewed and who gave it to you, minimum....if you want to acknowledge your undying love for said Geek, that's your choice.
6) Multiple cigars may be smoked and reviewed, limit of 5...but smoke em anyway, someone gave them to you for that purpose.
7) Random generator will be used to determine the winner, each cigar reviewed and posted in this thread is worth 1 entry, you may enter up to 5.

The winner will receive a handsome fiver from me...and if you didn't know already I don't smoke dog rockets...though I may go buy some to provide as a prize

*I reserve the right to modify the rules of this contest at any time and my say is final.
**No purchase required, alternate entry may be made by sending a postcard(to my mailbox), arriving no later than the contest deadline.

Any questions? No? Good, go forth and smoke those gifted cigars!   :dancing:
Title: RE: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: gitfiddl on 03/01/2016 04:42 PM
I'm in!  And thanks for the contest!

Title: RE: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: appollo on 03/01/2016 04:50 PM
Sounds interesting I,m in Thanks for the contest Brian. :biggrin:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: StogieDad on 03/01/2016 04:53 PM
Cool idea, I think I have a smoke or two somebody on here has sent me somewhere... :biggrin:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: Camshaft83 on 03/01/2016 06:06 PM
This is a great contest idea! And thanks for doing it!  :bigthumbs:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: headfirst on 03/01/2016 06:10 PM
Great idea Brian, I'll definitely play!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: danb6177 on 03/01/2016 06:21 PM
Great idea man.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: Rebecca Silverwolf on 03/01/2016 07:09 PM
Great idea. Thanks for the contest.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: tjm0831 on 03/01/2016 07:19 PM
Great contest! This will be fun!   :dancing:
Title: RE: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: Brlesq on 03/01/2016 07:19 PM
Quoteninfiction - 3/1/2016  7:41 PM
5) ....if you want to acknowledge your undying love for said Geek, that's your choice.

Great idea for a contest, Brian.  I've sent out a few Pineapple White Owls to members over the years, but I've never felt the love.  :lmao:

Title: RE: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: okieeagle on 03/01/2016 07:52 PM
This is going to be fun!! I've got a few sticks to smoke and a few geeks to thank for them!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: McBryde on 03/01/2016 08:01 PM
Well heck, 5 post cards is cheaper than 5 cigars for all you really cheap Geeks!

E
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: bmac7754 on 03/01/2016 08:36 PM
Great idea Brian.  I have a bunch to choose from.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: Ted on 03/02/2016 04:37 AM
Very cool idea, thanks for the contest! Will definitely try to get a few in this month!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: nirab on 03/02/2016 06:17 AM
Smoke cigars for a chance to win cigars???...count me in! Thanks Brian! :biggrin:  :bigthumbs:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: millarddj on 03/02/2016 07:14 AM
This is a terrific contest idea. I love seeing what people have to say on cigars, and need an excuse to smoke what people have sent me. :biggrin:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: Jackal on 03/02/2016 08:17 AM
Great idea.  Thanks for the contest.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: tjm0831 on 03/02/2016 11:44 AM
Just smoked a Tatuaje Havana VI Verocu No. 5 from ThinBlueLine as part of a blind 20 sampler.  You will find my review has been posted!  Not enough good words to say about Scott.  The sampler was out of this world, and from what I've tasted so far, I'm looking forward to burning through the remaining *24 sticks  :shy:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: ninfiction on 03/02/2016 12:34 PM
Awesome, we have our first entry! Nice review too.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: Vroomp on 03/02/2016 01:30 PM

QuoteJackal - 3/2/2016  11:17 AM  Great idea.  Thanks for the contest.

 Just don't burn your tit again Jason~!  :biggrin:

Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: headfirst on 03/03/2016 07:12 PM
Reviewed the Marco V Gigante Gold Label sent by millarddj from the Christmas Carol contest.  I expected something much different judging from Neal's review, and I'm guessing I just didn't get a good one.  Glad I got to try it though, thanks again Daniel.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: SenorPablo on 03/03/2016 07:21 PM
Such a cool contest.  Can't wait to see how it turns out.

-Paul
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: tjm0831 on 03/04/2016 06:23 AM
Just reviewed a Tatuaje Limited Release Cojonu 2012 Sumatra that I got from Brian (nirab) in a blind trade for a handful of Liga #9's.  Damn, that was an amazing cigar.  One of the best I've had recently.  I had a different, better experience with this smoke than the prior reviewers.  I can't recall if this was one in the trade proper or in the BOMB that came with the sticks.  Either way, Brian is the man.  Appreciate it brother.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: nirab on 03/04/2016 06:54 AM
Reviewed the La Palina Black Label Petite Lancero, given to me by Jon aka 1kappasig. Jon has this habit of bombing the shyte out of me every time we herf, and this was from one of those herfs last year. Good smoke from a great geek!!  :biggrin:  :bigthumbs:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: nirab on 03/04/2016 06:58 AM
Quotetjm0831 - 3/4/2016  8:23 AM

Just reviewed a Tatuaje Limited Release Cojonu 2012 Sumatra that I got from Brian (nirab) in a blind trade for a handful of Liga #9's.  Damn, that was an amazing cigar.  One of the best I've had recently.  I had a different, better experience with this smoke than the prior reviewers.  I can't recall if this was one in the trade proper or in the BOMB that came with the sticks.  Either way, Brian is the man.  Appreciate it brother.

Glad you enjoyed it! I'm not sure what sticks were what, but that is a great smoke. That one had some age on it too.  :biggrin:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: headfirst on 03/04/2016 08:48 AM
Just reviewed a Diesel Special Edition Corona courtesy of a trade with McBryde, that was a good smoke, thanks E! :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: ninfiction on 03/04/2016 08:57 AM
Excellent reviews guys! Keep em coming.
Title: RE: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: GrouchoM on 03/05/2016 12:35 AM
I'm new to the forum but would love to participate. Is that possible?
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: MacMac on 03/05/2016 03:43 AM
Quick question...Could the cigar be one purchased from another Geek or does it have to be a gift/bomb?
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: 05Venturer on 03/05/2016 09:53 AM
Just posted in my review of a Quintero (Cuban) (Quintero y Hermano) Favoritos given to me by John(aka Sparklepony) :dancing:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: 05Venturer on 03/05/2016 09:56 AM

QuoteMacMac - 3/5/2016  5:43 AM

Quick question...Could the cigar be one purchased from another Geek or does it have to be a gift/bomb?

"Here's the deal, smoke a cigar that another Geek(member of this forum) has given you, complete a review for the cigar, post here with the cigar name and the Geek's name the gave it to you and you're entered. Easy right? Yep, that's it. Smoke, type, win cigars.

 

Title: RE: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: ninfiction on 03/05/2016 09:58 AM
QuoteGrouchoM - 3/5/2016  2:35 AM

I'm new to the forum but would love to participate. Is that possible?

I limited the contest to Veteran Status or higher, which is 60 days on the site and 100 forum posts. Sorry you'll have to sit this one out, but you'll have all kinds of chances if you stick around.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: ninfiction on 03/05/2016 10:08 AM
QuoteMacMac - 3/5/2016  5:43 AM

Quick question...Could the cigar be one purchased from another Geek or does it have to be a gift/bomb?

I would prefer they were given to you, bombed or gifted or contest winnings....that being said, if you purchased a "fiver" but received 7 or 8 those extras could be considered gifts or if you bought a sampler for say $25 and ended up with double or triple that those "extras" could be considered gifts.

I'm not going to be doing background checks   :shy:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: MacMac on 03/05/2016 10:10 AM
Okay, got you.
Title: RE: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: appollo on 03/06/2016 01:38 PM
Just reviewed a Drew Estate Muwat Kentucky Fire Cured Just a Friend recieved from Chris[cmbrose] in the bombing run pass.I wanted to try one of these,but after this one there won't be another.
Title: RE: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: nirab on 03/06/2016 01:49 PM
Reviewed the Cabaiguan Guapos - Toro Grande Maduro, given to me in a pif from fellow geek Hebron. What a killer cigar!!!!  :biggrin:  :bigthumbs:
Title: RE: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: ninfiction on 03/06/2016 02:08 PM
Quoteappollo - 3/6/2016  3:38 PM

Just reviewed a Drew Estate Muwat Kentucky Fire Cured Just a Friend recieved from Chris[cmbrose] in the bombing run pass.I wanted to try one of these,but after this one there won't be another.

Very much how I feel about them.


Nice start to the contest guys!
Title: RE: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: appollo on 03/07/2016 12:00 PM
Reviewed a Drew Estate UnderCrown Shade Robusto I received from Joe [MacMac] as a prize in the ordinary Super bowl picks this year.Pretty good smoke for a Connecticut wrapper.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: Camshaft83 on 03/07/2016 02:32 PM
Just reviewed a Pinar del Rio Small Batch Exclusive Black Corojo Double Robusto I got from Nirab.  Pretty good cigar.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: StogieDad on 03/07/2016 03:41 PM
Just reviewed the Warped Don Reynaldo the Bruce sent me.  Fantastic cigar.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: Camshaft83 on 03/08/2016 11:54 AM
Just reviewed a Liga Privada #9 Belicoso I got from danb6177. Fantastic complex smoke.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: ninfiction on 03/08/2016 01:50 PM
Great job guys keep it up!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: headfirst on 03/09/2016 06:47 AM
Reviewed a Man O' War Puro Authentico Corona Maduro sent to me by Mike Casey in the weight loss contest.  Very good cigar, thanks Mike!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: Cfickter on 03/09/2016 07:58 AM
Great idea, I guess I need to begin smoking some!
Thanks for the contest
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: tjm0831 on 03/11/2016 07:06 AM
Just burned and reviewed an Anoranzas Churchill from Nathan (nwb) from a 15ct, whoops, 16ct, sampler!  Guess this one will be the extra!  Thanks brother!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: ninfiction on 03/11/2016 08:07 AM
Going to be a gorgeous weekend here, great time to smoke those gifted cigars!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: tjm0831 on 03/11/2016 08:21 AM
Quoteninfiction - 3/11/2016  10:07 AM

Going to be a gorgeous weekend here, great time to smoke those gifted cigars!

Louisiana's flooding again, but a good time to smoke cigars nonetheless!  (indoors of course  :shy: )
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: Mojo66 on 03/11/2016 08:32 AM
I had missed this. Great idea. I wanna play.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: appollo on 03/13/2016 05:55 PM
caldwell Iberian Express Murcias Especial Corona Gordo given to me by Stogiedad.Nice smoke thanks  :biggrin:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: tjm0831 on 03/13/2016 07:23 PM
Just reviewed an Alec Bradley Nica Puro Bajito and a Tatuaje Tattoo Caballero given to me as bonuses in an Oliva sampler from ThinBlueLine.  Thanks brother!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: nirab on 03/14/2016 06:04 AM
Reviewed the Emilio Draig K Corona I got from Bruce a couple of years ago.  :biggrin:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: nirab on 03/14/2016 10:28 AM
Reviewed the Room 101 Original 213, given to me by Stephen (sjn1117)...miss that geek...
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: tjm0831 on 03/14/2016 12:07 PM
Damn, just realized I maxed out my entries in this contest!  Guess I'll just have to keep smoking stogies from you guys anyway!   :cigarman:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: benchjockey on 03/15/2016 07:46 AM
Reviewed the La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor Reserva Maximo gifted to me by Secret Santa millarddj. Thanks, Daniel, for another outstanding smoke!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: ninfiction on 03/15/2016 10:47 AM
About halfway thru the month, lots of great entries so far. I'll see if I can get a list put together tonight to see where we're at. Keep em coming!
Title: RE: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: MacMac on 03/15/2016 07:29 PM
Reviewed a The Drew Estate Liga Privada Unico Serie Feral Flying Pig given to me by Longhorn.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: StogieDad on 03/16/2016 10:19 AM
Just put in a Diplomaticos No. 2 jharrisx5 sent me in a Wishlist PIF.  Thanks buddy!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: Camshaft83 on 03/16/2016 11:46 AM
A Crowned Heads Jericho Hill OBS given to me by millarddj. My favorite smoke I've had this year so far.  :bigthumbs:
Title: RE: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: appollo on 03/21/2016 10:19 AM
Received a Crowned Heads Las Calavers Edicion Lc52 from Brian ninfiction in a pif bomb.Thanks alot Brian great smoke really enjoyed it on the first day of spring.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: appollo on 03/21/2016 02:13 PM
Smoked a Padron Traditional Corticos given to me by Frank {Okieeagle] in a trade.Thanks Frank  :-)
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: bmac7754 on 03/21/2016 03:32 PM
Reviewed the Tatuaje Tattoo Universo I got in a bomb from Phog
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: bmac7754 on 03/22/2016 05:36 PM
Reviewed the Room 101 Original 404 I got in a bomb from Phog
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: ninfiction on 03/24/2016 02:31 PM
About a week left I believe, and Easter weekend to boot. i see you guys posting in the ..smoking...given to me by... thread, why not do a quick review and get an entry here!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: StogieDad on 03/24/2016 03:05 PM
A Perdomo 20th Anni Maduro Churchill that Kerry sent me in the FFL league winnings is now posted.  Good cigar.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: Camshaft83 on 03/24/2016 05:57 PM
A Panacea Black Maduro Robusto I got from millarddj. Pretty good smoke.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: tjm0831 on 03/27/2016 11:17 AM
I just smoked and reviewed a Tat Miami Reserva Series Petite Cazadores Reserva that I got from ThinBlueLine as a bonus with an Oliva sampler.  I know that I'm over the limit, but I thought that I would make the post anyway.  Thanks brother!  Great cigars, great Geek!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: benchjockey on 03/29/2016 07:24 AM
The owner of my local B&M claims he is the largest seller of the Leaf by Oscar in Florida. I told him I didn't need to buy any because Vroomp sent me one. He mumbled something about "never meeting a Vroomp he ever liked." My thanks to Brad for sending this maduro toro as part of the OAG PIF and have submitted my review.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: ninfiction on 03/29/2016 11:32 AM
Ok guys, only a couple days left, we'll cut this off about Midnight Central Thursday night...on Friday morning when I get around to putting together the list.

All names and cigars will go into a spread sheet, I'll attach and random number to each entry then use the good ole random number generator to a winner. May the odds be ever in your favor!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: headfirst on 03/29/2016 12:05 PM
Smoked a Flatbed Azul Robusto given to me by RDF in the Secret Santa exchange.  Not my fave but still glad to try it, thanks Randy!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: StogieDad on 03/31/2016 05:18 AM
Romeo y Julieta Reserve Maduro Toro I got from Sammy (sauraspop) a couple years ago.  Been a while since he was around.  Cool dude.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: headfirst on 03/31/2016 05:50 AM
For my 5th and final installment in the contest I smoked an AKA Nth Degree Apex given to me by nirab in the weight loss contest last year, good cigar.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: ninfiction on 04/01/2016 05:52 AM
Alright guys, give me some time to put the list together. We'll have a winner today.

Thanks to everyone that participated and added reviews to our database!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: nirab on 04/01/2016 05:54 AM
Thanks for running this contest Brian! If I don't win, I hope you do...good luck y'all!!  :biggrin:   :bigthumbs:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: appollo on 04/01/2016 06:13 AM
great contest Brian,good luck everyone  :-)
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: ninfiction on 04/01/2016 06:27 AM
Alright! 33 total entries of which 2 (Tat Tattoo and Room 101 Original) were reviewed by 2 geeks, but different vitolas.

I figured what the heck, 2 winners...

benchjockey was selected randomly first....and second, so I had to select again
Camshaft83 was the 2nd(3rd) winner.

I'll get your prizes packed up this weekend and dropped in the mail on Monday.

Thanks to everyone that participated...if anyone wants to see the spreadsheet and Random Number generator screenshots let me know.

Keep smoking those cigars that have been gifted!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: headfirst on 04/01/2016 06:33 AM
Congrats guys!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: MacMac on 04/01/2016 06:40 AM
Congratulations Geeks! Thanks for running the contest Brian! :cheer:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: benchjockey on 04/01/2016 06:43 AM
Thanks, Brian! Great way to start off the month.
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: Camshaft83 on 04/02/2016 09:47 PM
Thanks for the contest Brian! That will be an awesome package to come home from vacation too.  :bigthumbs:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: appollo on 04/03/2016 02:39 AM
Congrats guys  :thumbsup: Great contest Brian  :bigthumbs:
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: tjm0831 on 04/03/2016 04:47 AM
Congrats guys!
Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: Camshaft83 on 04/06/2016 10:53 AM
Got home from vacation late last night and went to go get my mail but the post office was not there. There was just a small package amidst all the rubble. Brian blew me away with this one. Thank you so very much!  :bow:
Title: RE: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: benchjockey on 04/06/2016 12:06 PM

It's nice to win a contest. It becomes special someone like Brian takes the time to check your wish list and is generous enough to send outstanding cigars.

Thanks so much, Brian! (http://www.cigargeeks.com/../images/emoticons/respekt.gif)

 (http://i145.photobucket.com/albums/r205/benchjockey/Brian%20ninfiction_zpsbgxg9ffh.jpg) (http://s145.photobucket.com/user/benchjockey/media/Brian%20ninfiction_zpsbgxg9ffh.jpg.html)

Title: Re: Contest: Review a Cigar given to you by a Geek
Post by: ninfiction on 04/06/2016 12:47 PM
Awesome! Glad you guys got the packages. Enjoy!

And thanks to everyone that took the time to be a part of the contest.