This critique has been generously sponsored by David and Andy at Cigars at Your Price:
http://www.cigarsatyourprice.com/
Thank you for your generosity! A special thank you goes out to Kevin (Wescat) for coordinating!
The Chosen Cigar: Camacho Liberty 2016
The Chosen Reviewers:
bstessl
Caveman Steve
Dave S.
DonM
nirab
This cigar shall be reviewed no later than July 25th.
Happy Smokin' gents! :smoker:
Reviewers will be chosen out of the pool of those that purchase under the group buy and show interest. For more information, see this thread:
http://www.cigargeeks.com/index.php?topic=42793.0
Quotenwb - 6/8/2016 7:58 AM
Reviewers will be chosen out of the pool of those that purchase under the group buy and show interest. For more information, see this thread:
http://www.cigargeeks.com/index.php?topic=42793.0
Thanks for setting this up Nathan. I'm definitely looking forward to this years Liberty.
I look forward to EVERY year's liberty!
I'll toss my hat in here if you have problems finding people. However I am doing one in oct,
As nwb has already said, the 5 Geek Critique'ers will be selected from the 2016 Camacho Liberty Distribution participants, as has been done for the past 5 years.
So, if you want in on the GC, buy a few !!
And, the chosen reviewers are:
nirab
cavemansteve
DonM
btessl
Dave S
Y'all enjoy, and I look forward to quality reviews turned in on time gentlemen !!
:dancing: Thank You Kevin ! Looking forward to the review
OK, cigars are going out this week.
So, what I need from each reviewer are replies to this thread, with:
Yes, I'll do the review.
I have received my Geek Critique cigar.
I will have my review submitted by *DATE*. And the date needs to be before 7/26/2016.
I really appreciate y'all doing these Geek Critique's !
Thank You !!!
So, what I need from each reviewer are replies to this thread, with:
Yes, I'll do the review. CHECK! :bigthumbs:
I have received my Geek Critique cigar. YES I HAVE!!!!
I will have my review submitted by *THE TIME BEFORE IT IS DUE*. And the date needs to be before 7/26/2016. ROGER THAT!!
I really appreciate ya doing these Geek Critique's ! I really appreciate ya doing this Liberty buy in every year!!
:biggrin: :bigthumbs:
Yes, I will definitely do the Geek Critique :bigthumbs:
I have a tracking number as of today on the cigars :bigthumbs:
I will have the review in by 20 July :bigthumbs:
Thanks again for setting the Camacho Liberty's up for us, I am looking forward to doing the review
I'm in on the GC (Thanks!)
pending arrival
I will have it done before said date, more exact estimate after arrival.
Quotewescat - 6/13/2016 1:54 PM
OK, cigars are going out this week.
So, what I need from each reviewer are replies to this thread, with:
1) Yes, I'll do the review.
2) I have received my Geek Critique cigar.
3) I will have my review submitted by *DATE*. And the date needs to be before 7/26/2016.
I really appreciate y'all doing these Geek Critique's !
Thank You !!!
Everyone should have their cigars in hand by now, so: Brian, Steve, Don, Brian, and Dave: please update this thread as per the 3 points of detail above if you haven't already. Thank you !!!
Looking forward to the reviews !! :cool:
Kevin--
First, thanks for the opportunity to participate in the Geek Critique, and I'll be pleased to do so.
Second, I haven't received my cigars, but, according to the tracking website, they're scheduled for delivery today.
Third, I'll submit my critique Sunday, July 24th. I'd like the cigars to spend as much time in my humidor as possible before I smoke one.
Take care,
Dave S.
QuoteDave S. - 6/22/2016 11:53 AM
Kevin--
First, thanks for the opportunity to participate in the Geek Critique, and I'll be pleased to do so.
Second, I haven't received my cigars, but, according to the tracking website, they're scheduled for delivery today.
Third, I'll submit my critique Sunday, July 24th. I'd like the cigars to spend as much time in my humidor as possible before I smoke one.
Take care,
Dave S.
Excellent, thank you Dave. :bigthumbs:
For future critiques, will there be future buy-ins to be eligible, or some other way of determining this? Sorry if I am asking this in the wrong area.
QuoteGameOfCigars - 6/22/2016 12:25 PM
For future critiques, will there be future buy-ins to be eligible, or some other way of determining this? Sorry if I am asking this in the wrong area.
Hello GameOfCigars. No problem asking the question, but the precise intent of your question is not clear to me.
If you ask regarding any/all Geek Critiques in the future, I cannot answer that definitively, but Geek Critique participants typically are gifted the cigar they are reviewing.
You can educate yourself regarding how Geek Critiques are done here: http://www.cigargeeks.com/index.php?action=articles;sa=view;article=39
And here: http://www.cigargeeks.com/index.php?topic=28848.0
If you ask regarding Geek Critiques of Camacho Liberty releases: I do a big box split on the Liberty's every year. 5 of the Geeks that buy in on the box split are selected to do the Geek Critique.
If you are asking because you want to buy in on this years liberty box split, see this thread: http://www.cigargeeks.com/index.php?topic=42793.0
If you are asking something else, please restate the question. Thanks.
I'm in on the GC
Cigars arrived nicely.
I will have it done most likely on the 3rd of July.
Quotebstessl - 6/22/2016 12:44 PM
I'm in on the GC
Cigars arrived nicely.
I will have it done most likely on the 3rd of July.
7/3/2016 is great Brian, thanks :bigthumbs:
My order of 10, plus the additional cigar for the critique arrived a few minutes ago.
QuoteDave S. - 6/22/2016 1:08 PM
My order of 10, plus the additional cigar for the critique arrived a few minutes ago.
Excellent Dave :bigthumbs: :bigthumbs:
original post updated to let you know that I received my cigars, along with the GC stick and that I will conduct my review before the stated deadline...see original post for more information... :biggrin: :shy:
Quotenirab - 6/22/2016 4:44 PM
original post updated to let you know that I received my cigars, along with the GC stick and that I will conduct my review before the stated deadline...see original post for more information... :biggrin: :shy:
Thanks Brian, looking forward to your review dude.
Received my cigars and will post my review before the stated deadline!
Thank You!
Enjoy guys, I did last years and it was a pretty good cigar, it wasn't the '07 but good
QuoteCfickter - 6/23/2016 11:43 AM
Enjoy guys, I did last years and it was a pretty good cigar, it wasn't the '07 but good
I still have an '07 that I got from Bruce in a trade. Haven't smoked it yet. Just waiting for the right time I guess
Seemed like a good afternoon to sit by the AC and do a Camacho Liberty 2016 review with a glass of sweet tea :shades:
QuoteDonM - 7/10/2016 1:46 PM
Seemed like a good afternoon to sit by the AC and do a Camacho Liberty 2016 review with a glass of sweet tea :shades:
Excellent Don, thanks for getting your review turned in early.
Brian, Steve, Brian, and Dave, are y'all all on track to have your review(s) turned in on time?
I will be doing mine this weekend... :biggrin: :bigthumbs:
7 days left to get these reviews in. Definitely looking forward to how much y'all liked it.
I got mine in this weekend. Thanks Kevin!! :biggrin: :bigthumbs:
Quotenirab - 7/18/2016 9:54 AM
I got mine in this weekend. Thanks Kevin!! :biggrin: :bigthumbs:
Excellent. Anybody else getting their review in early?
Quotewescat - 7/13/2016 7:23 AM QuoteDonM - 7/10/2016 1:46 PM Seemed like a good afternoon to sit by the AC and do a Camacho Liberty 2016 review with a glass of sweet tea :shades:
Excellent Don, thanks for getting your review turned in early. Brian, Steve, Brian, and Dave, are y'all all on track to have your review(s) turned in on time?
It's on my radar and will get done!
:biggrin:
QuoteCaveman Steve - 7/18/2016 8:52 PM
It's on my radar and will get done!
:biggrin:
Great, thanks Steve.
Review submitted! I had it done last weekend but got sidetracked submitting it. Thanks Kevin for the opportunity to do the review!
QuoteDonM - 7/24/2016 8:46 AM
Review submitted! I had it done last weekend but got sidetracked submitting it. Thanks Kevin for the opportunity to do the review!
Excellent, thanks Don :bigthumbs:
These are due in the morning.
Admins, can I get an update on who has/has not turned in their review?
Thanks y'all.
:biggrin:
Submitted mine last night. Really enjoyed it.
QuoteCaveman Steve - 7/25/2016 5:07 AM
Submitted mine last night. Really enjoyed it.
Excellent, thanks Steve. :bigthumbs:
They are all in.
-Paul
Quotewescat - 7/24/2016 8:37 PM
These are due in the morning.
Admins, can I get an update on who has/has not turned in their review?
Thanks y'all.
:biggrin:
QuoteSenorPablo - 7/25/2016 5:14 PM
They are all in.
-Paul
Quotewescat - 7/24/2016 8:37 PM
These are due in the morning.
Admins, can I get an update on who has/has not turned in their review?
Thanks y'all.
:biggrin:
Most excellent. Looking forward to reading them.
These will go live on 8/1/2016 ??
bstessl
Caveman Steve
Dave S.
DonM
nirab
I appreciate y'all getting your reviews in on time. :bigthumbs: :bigthumbs: :bigthumbs:
Wow, what a mixed bag of reviews! I must have got a good one, because I had a hard time deducting points. Thanks for putting on the review Kevin!
QuoteDonM - 8/2/2016 4:14 PM
Wow, what a mixed bag of reviews! I must have got a good one, because I had a hard time deducting points. Thanks for putting on the review Kevin!
Yup, good bit of spread in the reviews.