This critique has been generously sponsored by David at cigarsatyourprice.com:
http://www.cigarsatyourprice.com/
http://www.niceashcigars.com/Default.asp
http://www.egars.com/
Thank you for your generosity!
The Chosen Cigar: Camacho Liberty 2017
The Chosen Reviewers:
jharrisx5
klamm143
nirab
ninfiction
PETE314
This cigar shall be reviewed no later than August 25th.
Happy Smokin' gents! :smoker:
Thanks for setting up this thread Nathan.
I'm definitely looking forward to these reviews, what with the unique for a Liberty vitola and all.
Jason, Kevin, Brian, Brian and Peter: thank you for agreeing to review this cigar !!
Would each of you please respond to this thread, confirming that you:
1) Have received your review cigar from CAYP
2) Will submit your review before 8/26/2017
I appreciate it.
I have received and will absolutely have my review in by Aug 26th. Was planning on smoking it this weekend or next actually.
Thanks again for putting this together Kevin!
PM sent to Kevin..........My sticks are still showing as shipped (not yet received) - but yes I will definitely have my Critique done well before deadline.
Yes to both!
Sorry for taking a bit to reply... I'm in Vegas for the national youth trap shooting championships... My 10yr old is competing. Tomorrow is the finals so we'll see how he does. Shot a personal best today so it's looking decent!
Order received yesterday........4 ordered plus the one for critique........I'll have my critique done well before deadline........Thanks to Kevin and to CAYP - and all who work on putting this together for us.
I've received my cigars along with the review stick. I will have mine done well before the deadline...famous last words!! :biggrin:
I have received... Everything was perfect...I will review before August 26th!!!
Quoteninfiction - 7/13/2017 4:58 PM
I have received and will absolutely have my review in by Aug 26th. Was planning on smoking it this weekend or next actually.
Thanks again for putting this together Kevin!
You're welcome Brian.
Quotejharrisx5 - 7/15/2017 3:49 AM
Yes to both! Sorry for taking a bit to reply... I'm in Vegas for the national youth trap shooting championships... My 10yr old is competing. Tomorrow is the finals so we'll see how he does. Shot a personal best today so it's looking decent!
Great, thanks Jason. How did he do in the finals?
Quoteklamm143 - 7/15/2017 11:40 AM
Order received yesterday........4 ordered plus the one for critique........I'll have my critique done well before deadline........Thanks to Kevin and to CAYP - and all who work on putting this together for us.
Great, thanks Kevin.
Quotenirab - 7/17/2017 5:35 PM
I've received my cigars along with the review stick. I will have mine done well before the deadline...famous last words!! :biggrin:
Great, thanks Brian.
QuotePETE314 - 7/21/2017 12:07 AM
I have received... Everything was perfect...I will review before August 26th!!!
Great, thanks Pete.
All is in order, most excellent.
He did well.. Individually 10th in his division
His 3 person shooting squad took 2nd which was pretty exciting... He was the squads top shooter
Quotejharrisx5 - 7/24/2017 12:18 PM
He did well.. Individually 10th in his division
His 3 person shooting squad took 2nd which was pretty exciting... He was the squads top shooter
You gotta be a damn proud papa with those results. :bigthumbs:
Review complete.
Thank you Kevin and David for the opportunity!
Quoteninfiction - 8/4/2017 9:05 PM
Review complete.
Thank you Kevin and David for the opportunity!
Thanks for getting it in early Brian. :bigthumbs:
This is a quick reminder that there is one week left to get these submitted.
Thanks!
Mine is in.............thanks for working the magic and fixing "THE LINK" Nathan - and thanks to David and Kevin for all the work and dedication.
Quoteklamm143 - 8/19/2017 7:07 AM
Mine is in.............thanks for working the magic and fixing "THE LINK" Nathan - and thanks to David and Kevin for all the work and dedication.
Thanks for getting it in early Kevin. :bigthumbs:
No problem Sir...........Thank you for letting me participate, fielding my calls / PM's and the time and effort you put into this yearly event.
I just submitted my review. Man, this Liberty 2017 is one... :shy:
Hopefully tomorrow....
Quotenirab - 8/21/2017 8:37 PM
I just submitted my review. Man, this Liberty 2017 is one... :shy:
Excellent, thanks Brian. :bigthumbs:
Done...wow
4 of the 5 are in. Thanks folks!
Quotenwb - 8/23/2017 1:01 PM
4 of the 5 are in. Thanks folks!
A testament to your admin powers methinks. :bigthumbs:
Quotejharrisx5 - 8/23/2017 3:47 AM
Done...wow
Excellent, thanks Jason. :bigthumbs:
Sorry...missed your last email...Review was completed Friday...Thank you so much for choosing me to be a part of it.
Thanks go out to Kevin for coordinating and everyone for getting their reviews in on time!
QuotePETE314 - 8/28/2017 8:49 AM
Sorry...missed your last email...Review was completed Friday...Thank you so much for choosing me to be a part of it.
Excellent, thanks Pete. :bigthumbs:
Admins, thanks for getting the GC's linked up.
Good, well written reviews. I appreciate it.
And......Thank You AGAIN......for allowing us to participate - and all the work and hours put in to make it all happen.
Hmm apparently I was the only one with a poor experience. Maybe I need to revisit sooner rather than later.
Quoteninfiction - 9/1/2017 11:56 PM
Hmm apparently I was the only one with a poor experience. Maybe I need to revisit sooner rather than later.
Sounds right. I thought your 80 points was generous when you thought that most of the cigar tasted like second hand smoke.