Cigar Geeks

Members Lounge => General Cigar Discussion => Topic started by: Fermentedleaves on 05/06/2020 12:02 PM

Title: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: Fermentedleaves on 05/06/2020 12:02 PM
While I have found what I like primarily in a cigar and certain brands I wonder if anyone practices monogamy with a cigar. I have heard rumors that some indivuduals only smoke one brand, forsaking all others. Anyone here like this?
Title: RE: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: Brlesq on 05/06/2020 12:51 PM
Limiting oneself to a single brand isn't monogamous.  Some brands have dozens of individual cigar names and blends. That's more akin to limiting yourself to your wife AND all of her relatives.

Limiting yourself to a single named cigar, well that's monogamous, and probably monotonous as well.  :rolleyes:

Title: RE: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: arrow34 on 05/06/2020 02:08 PM
QuoteBrlesq - 5/6/2020  1:51 PM

Limiting oneself to a single brand isn't monogamous.  Some brands have dozens of individual cigar names and blends. That's more akin to limiting yourself to your wife AND all of her relatives.

Limiting yourself to a single named cigar, well that's monogamous, and probably monotonous as well.  :rolleyes:


Well said bruce.
Title: RE: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: mhuss on 05/06/2020 03:01 PM
Yes, very well said Bruce.  In addition to that, I think you'll have a very difficult time finding someone here who smokes only one brand of cigar.  Just like almost anything else, I think trying new brands is part of the excitement of enjoying things like cigars.  I do the same thing with beer, rum, cheesesteak shops, you name it.  You never know when you're coming across your new favorite.  If you'd never try another brand, you'd never know if you like anything else.
Title: RE: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: Fermentedleaves on 05/06/2020 03:15 PM
Yeah in hindsight I probably shouldn't of said "brand" but rather "one cigar". And I agree it would be really hard to find someone who only smokes "one cigar" in response to the other comment. However it doesn't mean it doesn't exist! I am willing to bet there is someone out there and because of that I find that possible person to have a unique perspective on things than those the polyamory view of cigars.

This search relates to something I want to write on this subject so I am digging everywhere.
Title: Re: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: arrow34 on 05/06/2020 04:16 PM
The community here might be the wrong one to ask... Like mhuss said.. I tend to rotate out cigars and get new cigars when they come out.  You would be hard pressed to find someone that only smokes his favorite cigar and nothing else....
Title: Re: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: Brlesq on 05/06/2020 04:26 PM
Quotearrow34 - 5/6/2020  5:16 PM

The community here might be the wrong one to ask... Like mhuss said.. I tend to rotate out cigars and get new cigars when they come out.  You would be hard pressed to find someone that only smokes his favorite cigar and nothing else....

Yeah, when we've asked the proverbial questions like "If you lived on a deserted island and could only smoke 5 cigars . . . ", people here have trouble picking their top 5, let alone 1.

I am monogamous to every cigar that I begin to smoke, until it is just a stub and pile of ashes and no longer the cigar that I started. And then I'm monogamous to the next cigar in the exact same manner.  :shy:

Title: Re: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: StogieDad on 05/06/2020 06:46 PM
Men weren't built to be monogamous...:lmao:
Title: Re: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: DRuff on 05/06/2020 08:25 PM
I used to only smoke 2 particular cigars until the Chief Enabler, BRLESQ got me started smoking others. Now I have a ridiculous assortment. Why limit yourself?
Title: Re: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: headfirst on 05/07/2020 12:16 AM
I ran into someone that said they only smoke OpusX.  While I'm sure they're great (I have a few I've been hoarding and not trying  :banghead: ) I couldn't help but feel like the guy is missing a lot by being snobbish about only smoking what he thought was the very best cigars had to offer.  And I have a feeling he has no idea what all is really out there, just going with an expensive well known brand name as his go-to...
Title: Re: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: ntanner on 05/07/2020 08:17 AM
Variety is the spice of life. Smoking just one cigar would be not only monotonous but would lead to a bland life and nobody wants bland. :biggrin:
Title: Re: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: Cfickter on 05/07/2020 12:44 PM
There used to be guy at a local lounge who saaid he only smoked Joya de Monterey Excalibur No. 2s.  That is all I ever saw him smoke.
but for me there is a reason, at least for cigars, that monogamy and monotony are close!
Title: Re: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: klamm143 on 05/08/2020 05:27 PM
I can't stick to just one of anything - just ask my EX-WIVES!!!!!
Title: Re: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: jagfandaddy on 05/08/2020 06:21 PM
While I do enjoy a few particular cigars, I would never stick to just one. You would never know if there is another you would like better
Title: Re: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: Otter on 05/10/2020 02:07 PM
We had a customer that not only would only some one "brand" of cigar, but only one vitola in that brand - wouldn't take my advice or recommendations - to each his own!
Title: Re: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: sweatsock on 05/13/2020 07:34 PM
It only shows inflexibility. That one cigar will never be exactly the same flavor. I've seen another question that makes more sense; if you could only smoke one cigar what would It be?
Title: Re: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: junglepete on 05/14/2020 08:16 AM
I have a friend who only smokes Flor del Todo Maduro large ring cigars. He says he likes the wide open draw with tons of smoke. He goes through a few a day. When he's in Mexico for the other half of the year, he only smokes a local Cohiba knock off.
Title: Re: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: Beegerply on 05/14/2020 03:13 PM
Quotesweatsock - 5/13/2020  10:34 PM

It only shows inflexibility. That one cigar will never be exactly the same flavor. I've seen another question that makes more sense; if you could only smoke one cigar what would It be?

The one that's in my hand  :biggrin:
Title: Re: Monogamy and Cigars
Post by: ljlemer on 07/04/2020 07:14 PM
I'm promiscuous. My smoking consists of hardly ever smoking the same cigar twice. A rare exception happened very recently. I ordered my favorite Cuban cigars, Cohibas. The reason I don't order cigars I've already smoked is because I can only review them once. My obsession is my Cigar Geeks score. I smoked 5 Genios Maduros and 5 Magicos Maduros. I'm satisfied that they were genuine. They were also a big disappointment. The flavor lacked the same tangy complexity I loved, but the biggest problem was the tight draw. I poked them numerous times with flattened paper clips. It didn't help much. I got bad smokes and no review points.