Welcome to CG Aaron.
I like Brlesq suggestion, get rid of those unwanted cigars by sending them to the 2014 Cigars for Troops effort. You'll make room for new, better cigars and get some street cred at the same time. It's a win win.
But first, you should get more, bigger humidors just in case you catch the CG bug. Once infected, you won't be able to stop the flow of cigars coming in.