Best AF Hemingway Classic Critique

[SenorPablo]

So we have our 4 Geek Critiques in for the AF Hemingway Classic.  All look excellent, but i'd like to put them to a vote about who the members think did the best job.  Our next lineup is in for review and it is the AF Don Carlos so we need another set of reviewers.  I figured i'd let this vote help determine which 1 or 2 stay for the next review and then we'll cycle a few more new members in as well.

So the question is which one do you think is best?  Keep in mind the votes are anonymous so don't worry about what anyone thinks.

For reference, here are the links to all 4 Geek Critiques:
http://www.cigargeeks.com/index.php?action=cigrevs;area=showcrit;gc_id=7
http://www.cigargeeks.com/index.php?action=cigrevs;area=showcrit;gc_id=8
http://www.cigargeeks.com/index.php?action=cigrevs;area=showcrit;gc_id=9
http://www.cigargeeks.com/index.php?action=cigrevs;area=showcrit;gc_id=10

[podman28]

All were good reviews but Junglepete was just a bit more detailed in my opinion. I do appreciate all of the reviews though.

[Bob Cordell]

I thought all the reviews were great. I'm also keeping my vote a secret!


Shhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!

[SenorPablo]

It started out interesting.  It was a 4 way tie with each one with 1 vote.  Then junglepete started to pull away.  There's still plenty of more room for voting though.

[Bob Cordell]

All four guys went into detail and really took their task seriously I think. They should all be applauded but in the end only a couple can move on...

[BlackIrish]

I'll keep my vote secret but will say that it was a tough decision, because I thought all of the critiques were thoughtful, well-written, and really valuable.  Thanks, guys!