I have both a mesh bag and two of the metal containers that you linked to. The reason I love the containers is because they're a perfect fit for the smaller humidors that are designed to hold rectangular humidifiers. One of my humi's had a standalone cedar humidifier holder that operates as a divider as well, cutting down on wasted space. This metal case fits in that divider like a glove. The bag is great too. Since I don't have enough room for everything since I bought my box of Liberty 2013's, I made some room in the box and put the mesh bag in there. I put it on a bit of plastic wrap though, I don't know if I'd put cigars on it. When you rehydrate it you never know when some excess water might come out of it.