Just saw the reviews -- although there's some variation in the numbers, the descriptions seem very consistent. I thought that I might have had an outlier with the too easy draw and underfilling, it seems that this was consistent across the board.
I think my numbers are lower because I took off more points for the draw and the underfill. My reasoning: these issues are problems in construction, which is more objective and less subjective than flavor, and therefore I grade them a little harder.
As I said in my review, I think that there is quality tobacco in this cigar -- I wish there was just a little more.
Thanks to everyone for the chance to participate in this critique!