I tried scissors once at my local lounge. It was terrible, the cut was far from clean. I feel like I could have gotten a cleaner cut by rolling the window of my car up on the end of my cigar. So, I swore them off for ever. However, seeing as how you all seem to have had good luck I'm beginning to think the pair I tried were probably just not in good shape. Perhaps I'd give them another go, but even if it cuts cleanly I don't really see a benefit over a guillotine cutter.