So here's what I did. I did remove all the bands, bagged them up and tossed them in the box. I numbered each of the cigars with blank bands and kept a list of what's what. After the P&Ts are done you can send me a note and I'll let you know what you selected.
Each person has the option to also take the bands off their puts and and use one of the blank bands I included in the pass to number them or just make your puts like normal. If you do take the bands off shoot me a pm with your puts and the number you gave them and I'll keep my list updated.
I'm not telling what anyone picked until you update your P&Ts, I'm kind of a dick like that...and honestly they are all good cigars so you're not going to get hosed.
Ok Ok I'm not a complete dick, if you really don't want to play along just shoot me a pm and I'll send you the list when you get the box. This should be fun for everyone.