(Edit: For posterity, since I got suckered into the same necro-thread twice) Woodford Reserve is respectable as a sipping whiskey and as a mixer. Makers Mark is more of mixer, so if you think you're going to serve only mixed drinks, its a good choice. Basil Hayden is an accessible "premium" bourbon if you have an avid bourbon fan on your hands. I'd avoid Bulleit in all their forms; its fine, but over priced IMO. Jim Beam punches above their price and is a good mixer and an acceptable sipping whiskey. Belle Meade is on the sweet end of the range, as is 40 Creek. Wild Turkey 101 is tough to beat in value/quality. Wild Turkey Rare Breed is probably the best and most affordable cask strength.