I'm one of those guys who doesn't have a wishlist and while I definitely see the value since it clearly helped me in my being Santa (the giver) for my "kid", i don't have the time.
As for me on the receiving end, I still don't know what I don't know. There are sooooo many good cigars and some that I like, you guys might think of as dogs. I really enjoy the aspect of trying new things and what I love about this site it that you get to see what others are smoking and rating.
So for this years Secret Santa, whether it's a reasonable Rocky, MF or Drew Estates, to a higher end Padron, Liga or Davidoff, I am honestly just excited to see what's in the mail. Looking forward to it is half the excitement and no matter what I get, I won't be dissapointed.. well unless it's a Gurkha