August 2023 Member Sponsored Geek Critique - Blind Review

appollo · 07/06/2023 08:43 AM

So everyone has their sticks just a reminder please have them done by the 25th.Enjoy and have fun trying to guess.TRhere will be a 5pak if we have a winner.

BewareDaPenguin · 07/06/2023 04:42 PM

Quote from: appollo on 07/06/2023 08:43 AMSo everyone has their sticks just a reminder please have them done by the 25th.Enjoy and have fun trying to guess.TRhere will be a 5pak if we have a winner.

Ahhh yes! Thanks for the reminder!!!

Murphy223 · 07/07/2023 08:04 AM

Will get this done this wknd or next. Hopefully sooner

Brlesq · 07/16/2023 10:34 AM

Friendly reminder: Due Date is July 25, so that the rest of this weekend, and all of next weekend, to get your critique turned in. Thanks!

Murphy223 · 07/20/2023 12:08 PM

Review Submitted!

appollo · 07/20/2023 05:38 PM

Quote from: Murphy223 on 07/20/2023 12:08 PMReview Submitted!

Hope you enjoyed it

BewareDaPenguin · 07/21/2023 12:10 PM

It's on the docket for this weekend, will get my guess over

quickme · 07/21/2023 11:26 PM

Submitted mine but not sure I did it correctly. It was an EXCELLENT stick and looking forward to hearing what it is. Box worthy IMO. Thank you Stephen for the experience

appollo · 07/22/2023 04:49 AM

Quote from: quickme on 07/21/2023 11:26 PMSubmitted mine but not sure I did it correctly. It was an EXCELLENT stick and looking forward to hearing what it is. Box worthy IMO. Thank you Stephen for the experience

Glad you liked it Nick.

Brlesq · 07/23/2023 11:00 AM

Friendly reminder: Two (2) days left to complete these. (July 25). Thanks!

BewareDaPenguin · 07/23/2023 04:53 PM

Critique submitted!!! Thanks again!!

ninfiction · 07/24/2023 08:57 PM

I have no idea what that was but damn I enjoyed that. Looking forward to seeing the rest of the reviews.

Thank you Stephen!

appollo · 07/25/2023 04:15 PM

Quote from: ninfiction on 07/24/2023 08:57 PMI have no idea what that was but damn I enjoyed that. Looking forward to seeing the rest of the reviews.

Thank you Stephen!

Glad you liked it Brian.Its One my favorites

BewareDaPenguin · 07/26/2023 11:22 AM

Sounds like it's going to score pretty high, I really enjoyed mine as well, wrapper just had a little bit of damage but I didn't ding it too much...am interested to see "what it is"

and how we stacked up!

Brlesq · 07/30/2023 11:10 AM

Interesting and quite varied reviews on this cigar. I can't disclose the cigar or the scores yet, but I will tell you the guesses anonymously (to protect the innocent

), but you are welcome to claim your guess if you want to:

A.J. Fernandez New World Dorado
Crowned Heads CHC Serie E Hermosa No. 2
Don Pepin Garcia (My Father Cigars) La Opulencia Torpedo
Roma Craft Tobac CroMagnon EMH
Tatuaje 7th Tuxtla

BewareDaPenguin · 07/30/2023 05:19 PM

Quote from: Brlesq on 07/30/2023 11:10 AMInteresting and quite varied reviews on this cigar. I can't disclose the cigar or the scores yet, but I will tell you the guesses anonymously (to protect the innocent ), but you are welcome to claim your guess if you want to:

A.J. Fernandez New World Dorado
Crowned Heads CHC Serie E Hermosa No. 2
Don Pepin Garcia (My Father Cigars) La Opulencia Torpedo
Roma Craft Tobac CroMagnon EMH
Tatuaje 7th Tuxtla

I'm sure I missed it lol...I guessed the Don Peppin lol - what did Nirab guess? That's probably it!

Murphy223 · 07/30/2023 06:24 PM

The suspense is killing me 😬😬😬

ninfiction · 07/30/2023 07:19 PM

I guessed the Tatuaje...just seemed like a decent guess, not even sure the cigar I chose matched the cigar I smoked size wise. I really didn't have a decent guess as to what it was.

Murphy223 · 08/01/2023 04:41 PM

We'll? It's August

What was it???

appollo · 08/01/2023 06:02 PM

Going to wait till its posted

Brlesq · 08/01/2023 06:58 PM

Quote from: appollo on 08/01/2023 06:02 PMGoing to wait till its posted

Just waiting on SenorPablo to push it to the forum

SenorPablo · 08/01/2023 07:09 PM

Quote from: Brlesq on 08/01/2023 06:58 PM
Quote from: appollo on 08/01/2023 06:02 PMGoing to wait till its posted

Just waiting on SenorPablo to push it to the forum

Sorry guys. Should be up shortly.

-Paul

appollo · 08/02/2023 04:15 AM

Glad everyone liked the stick.Feels good to finally stump the master.Thanks everyone for taking part in the critique,enjoyed reading the reviews.

Murphy223 · 08/02/2023 06:45 AM

Quote from: appollo on 08/02/2023 04:15 AMGlad everyone liked the stick.Feels good to finally stump the master.Thanks everyone for taking part in the critique,enjoyed reading the reviews.

Good smoke. Definitely picking some up. Thanks

BewareDaPenguin · 08/02/2023 09:57 AM

Yeah I had no clue but I certainly enjoyed it! Thanks so much for including me again Appollo!

You stumped the whole group! Congrats!

Maybe 1 of these years I'll come close lol, probably not