I had a Lot 23, but it wasn't the maduro. I gave it 4 stars. Lots of delicious flavors, very enjoyable. I remember it getting a little bitter toward the end, which I think I knocked it down a half-star for that. It really could have gotten a 4.5. But it was great nonetheless. I imagine the maduro would be even better, at least in my opinion. I tend to prefer maduro's.